Corporate Governance Code Compliance In Hong Kong Slightly Improves
来源:CFO innovation 更新时间:2014/12/19 阅读次数:108
The number of Hang Seng Composite Index (HSCI) companies that claimed full compliance with the Hong Kong Corporate Governance Code slightly rose from 34% to 37%, even though many offered little detail on how they complied, according to the Grant Thornton Hong Kong Corporate Governance Review 2014.
Only five out of the 387 HSCI companies provided any disclosure regarding the results or findings of their internal control review.
“While Hong Kong companies have come a long way in adopting corporate governance measures, there are still areas for improvement. This is evident in the string of corporate fraud and accountability issues at Mainland companies and corruption scandals in blue chip Hong Kong companies that have occurred over the last year,” said Eugene Ha, advisory partner at Grant Thornton Hong Kong Limited.
“For Hong Kong to maintain its status as a global financial centre, it is crucial that corporate governance becomes a cornerstone of the business strategy for companies that are listed or are looking to list here, and that their financial information is prepared in line with international accounting standards,” he added.
Leadership and Board Effectiveness
The Code requires that companies hold at least four board meetings, attended by the majority of its directors, a year.
Approximately 8% of the companies still did not comply, and 1% held less than one board meeting during the year.
One of the code provisions with the lowest compliance rate is the separation of the role of chairman and chief executive. Consistent with last year, 30% of companies were helmed by one individual acting as both the chairman as well as the chief executive.
Diversity
Eighty-four percent of HSCI companies disclosed a diversity policy. This compared with 83% last year. The industries with the highest and lowest percentage of compliance to the new code provision were Information Technology at 92%, and Industrial Goods at 78%, respectively.
Although research has shown that more diverse companies outperform their less diverse peers, the boards of over half (56%) of HSCI companies were made up of no or less than 10% of female directors. Last year, this figure stood at 65%.
Accountability and Risk Management
Nearly half (45%) of HSCI companies included a statement regarding risk management in their annual reports. While only 29% provided insight into how they reviewed the effectiveness of their internal control systems.
There was an increase in the number of companies that disclosed a whistleblower program, a recommended best practice within the Code, from 23% to 27%. However, only 12% communicated their whistleblower policy on their company websites or disclosed details for stakeholders to report fraud and improprieties.
The majority of companies (96%) held at least two audit committee meetings during the year, and consistent with last year, more than half (59%) organised three or more meetings.
Information Technology
Even as companies increased their investment and reliance on IT systems, only 15% reported having an IT strategy in place that would cover major system upgrades or new system investments.
A mere 4% said they had a cyber security or information security plan while 8% mentioned their cyber security and information security in their annual reports.
This is the first time Grant Thornton has included a review on IT security and management in the Hong Kong Corporate Governance Review. As the impact of technology on businesses increases, Grant Thornton recommends that companies increase transparency in IT risk management and information system management and include these two aspects into their board oversight and risk management framework.
Shareholder Relations
Over half (57%) of HSCI companies stated either in their annual reports or on their websites that they had a communications policy in place. In addition, almost all of them (96%) valued communications and relationship with shareholders.
“It goes without saying that good corporate governance is critical in maintaining Hong Kong’s long term competitiveness and status as an international financial centre against other leading commercial hubs like Singapore, New York and London. But what makes this a more pressing challenge for the SAR is the rapid assimilation of its economy with that of mainland China. The business community here needs to strike a balance between growing business opportunities and complying with regulatory traditions,” said Eugene Ha.
“The thing to remember is, investors are savvy and they know that strong governance is an important market differentiator and can mean the difference between a good and bad investment,” he concluded.
