Moreover, industry experts have identified poor corporate governance, government ownership and control, lack of independent board, inappropriate segmentation as some of the major issues responsible for the collapse of NITEL. Ernest Ndukwe, former, executive vice chairman, Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) earlier in the year corroborated the factors mentioned.
“Lack of corporate governance practice was one of the reasons for the collapse of NITEL. “This is because at a time NITEL was at its peak, it had staff strength of about 15,000 people, who were only looking after 400,000 lines. MTN has about 30million subscribers and has about 5290 workers. So, when you carry a lot of load, sometimes it becomes too heavy for the organisation. “More so, because NITEL is called a government parastatal, it lacked focus”, he explained.
“You would not believe that NITEL never had a sales department! They did not do marketing, because people come to them. So, when it was time to get them to market, they did not have any body who could market them. My prayer is that this present privatisation process will succeed. I feel that NITEL still has some potentials, it could still rise again”, he added.
Commenting on what could be done to save the once valued conglomerate; Ndukwe said that what was required to revive NITEL was a good professional management, with the needed independence that is required to turn the company around: “In this kind of business, you give the managing director a target and if he does not meet it, you fire him and replace him with somebody else. That is what people do in other organisations. Since telecom started, I am sure the present managing director of MTN is the third or fourth. If a manager is doing well, he can last for 10 years, but if he fails to meet his target, the organisation will bring in some one else.”
In the same vein, Lanre Ajayi, president, Nigerian Internet Group (NIG) who spoke to BusinessDay in a telephone conversation said that NITEL was a company duly registered by the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC), a multi-billion naira organisation, which should have an independent board and management to run it profitably. This, regrettably, did not come to pass. Commenting on the viability of NITEL, he noted: “Of course, NITEL can be saved and managed. NITEL has huge infrastructure and asset on ground. What the company need is first-class management and large degree of independence is required to achieve this. They also need skilled human assets to ensure that these assets are managed properly.”
On the contrary, Emmanuel Ekuwem, former, president, Association of Telecommunications Companies of Nigeria (ATCON) and chief executive officer (CEO), Teledom Group stated that NITEL can be revived if the government would allow competent professionals manage its affairs. He frowned at the privatisation of the organisation, stating that telecoms national carriers such as NITEL in other nations of the world are thriving successfully. Ekuwem noted that there was hope for the organisation if the right people are given the opportunity to control its affairs.
Skeptics have argued that NITEL from inception was designed to fail, adding that the high level of political interference that had plagued the company was most times driven by personal interests. “Many governments saw NITEL as a milking cow and, of course, when the transition came to liberalise the environment, NITEL operators could not cope with the kind of processes they had”, an informed source to Business Day recently.
According to him, NITEL’s decade of redundancy may have reduced its value to zero. Titi Omo-Ettu, president, Association of Telecommunications Companies of Nigeria (ATCON) totally disagrees with this claim. “I am looking at the license which NITEL has and it is worth $2.2 billion. The bidder who came with the $2.5 billion is not stupid; they know NITEL is worth every cent.”
Earlier, the result of the bid for NITEL was released on 16 February with New Generation Consortium emerging as the preferred bidder, with a bid of $2.5 billion. Shortly after the result was announced, the technical partner of the preferred bidder, China Unicom, denied any involvement with the consortium. Thus, with all the controversial issues associated with the bidders of NITEL, the National Council of Privatisation (NCP) set up a seven man ad-hoc committee on 12 March to review the bidding process of NITEL.
Nevertheless, If NCP goes ahead to ratify the bid results and issue the consortium a letter formally confirming it as the preferred bidder, New Generation would be expected to within 10 calendar days of the receipt of the confirmation, pay $750 million, about N112.5 billion) after deducting the initial payment for bid security. This translates to $749.81, or N112.472 billion, after which the balance of $1.75 billion or N262.5 billion would be expected to be wired to the relevant government account within 60 days.
Some industry analysts still question the ability of the company to raise the fund. Since 2001, all the previous winners in the privatisation of NITEL have failed to meet up the payment deadlines and this raises doubts about the ability of the new bid winner to raise the $2.5 billion. They have wondered where an unknown company like New Generations would raise such amounts of money especially at a time when the nation’s economy was experiencing one of the worst security assurance ratings on investments.
