HSBC succession puts corporate governance back under spotlight


更新时间:2010/05/27 阅读次数:201

By Kate Burgess and Patrick Jenkins

Published: May 26 2010 03:00 | Last updated: May 26 2010 03:00

Six months ago HSBC shifted its centre of gravity to Hong Kong and Stephen Green, executive chairman, handed over strategic decision making to Michael Geoghegan, its chief executive now based in Asia.

In the process, it signalled to its top shareholders that it was moving towards the kind of corporate governance structure - involving a chief executive and a non-executive chairman - that has become normal in the UK. It seemed to be only a matter of time before Mr Green retired, to be replaced by a non-executive chairman. But now the bank appears to be having second thoughts.

Mr Green is telling the world he is staying on as executive chairman for at least a year and maybe two. He wants to oversee the restructuring of HSBC's disastrous incursion into US consumer finance at the height of the credit bubble. He is also reluctant to step down when the bank and the industry face so many challenges, including the looming sovereign debt crisis. Insiders at the bank say now is not the time for it to radically restructure its governance and move away from having a fully committed chairman.

Nonetheless, planning Mr Green's succession has become a priority for the bank's board. It threatens to pit the banks' directors, its biggest shareholders and regulators against each other. It will also have implications for the governance of other multinational companies, particularly those, such as Prudential, looking to shift their power bases to Asia.

Until recently, HSBC's favoured option had been to appoint John Thornton as non-executive chairman. He has been an HSBC non-executive director since 2008, was made non-executive chairman of its US operations, has far-reaching connections in China and is a former Goldman Sachs president. The move had already won tacit approval from key shareholders.

But that scenario has faded into the background. One option is to promote one of the bank's existing non-executive directors or bring in someone from outside the group to act as non-executive chairman.

A more contentious proposal is to elevate Mr Geoghegan to executive chairman in Asia and appoint a chief executive in London. Those close to the bank suggest the three possible candidates for chief executive are Stuart Gulliver, investment banking chief and current favourite, Douglas Flint, the bank's finance director, and Sandy Flockhart, chairman of personal and commercial banking.

HSBC has long had an executive chairman, arguing that the chairman needs to have executive status to negotiate at the highest levels in regions where a non-executive status is not well understood. The bank has also historically drawn its chairman from the ranks of its own executives. This used to be common among UK banks but most have abandoned the practice in favour of a more standard structure involving a non-executive chairman and a chief executive.

Many investors hope that Mr Green - who has been at HSBC since 1982 - would be the last executive of a UK bank to make it to chairman.

Therefore promoting Mr Geoghegan, who has been at HSBC since 1973, to executive chairman risks creating friction.

Corporate governance experts believe that there should be a clear line between the job of chief executive and chairman. The UK's code on good governance says: "There should be a clear division of responsibilities at the head of the company between the running of the board and the executive responsibility for the running of the company's business. No one individual should have unfettered powers of decision."

HSBC's biggest investors are more pragmatic about the division of roles. "Being chairman of HSBC is a five day a week job," says one of the bank's top five shareholders. The important thing, he added in an echo of one of the top UK regulators, is to split the power at the top of the bank, whether the positions are defined as executive or not. Investors also concede the advantages of a chairman who is not new to HSBC's complex international businesses.

However, shareholders draw the line at the next chairman being a former HSBC executive. They fear that executives-turned-chairmen exert too much power over their replacements, stifle change and go out of their way to protect their legacies.

That is why Mr Geoghegan should not be chairman, say several leading investors. Equally, that is why Mr Thornton would be such a good candidate for the job, says a leading investor. "He has vast financial experience, he is embedded in Asia and he is not a novice to HSBC having been on the board for nearly two years. He would also be non-executive."

However, an HSBC insider says Mr Thornton "divides opinions on the board" and questions whether Mr Thornton - who spends most of his time in Washington and Asia - would base himself in London as requested by London's chief City regulator. The Financial Services Authority sanctioned the chief executive's job shifting to Hong Kong earlier this year on the understanding that the bank would ensure his power base would be balanced by a "robust" chairman.

The board faces some tough decisions. Fortunately, given Mr Green's renewed commitment, it has some time to make them.