By Anthony Skinner
Ask the owner of a company in Anatolia about the strength of corporate governance in Turkey and you are likely to get a blank look. While Turkey has made bold strides in the past decade, it still lags behind many developed economies in corporate governance.
This is reflected in the World Bank’s Doing Business 2010 survey, where Turkey ranks 73rd out of 183 economies. The country scores a disappointing 5.7 out of 10 for the strength of investor protection, despite boasting an impressive nine out of 10 for the transparency of transactions. Its average number of 35 procedures to enforce contracts is above that of the OECD as a whole (30.6).
Two primary concerns relating to corporate governance in Turkey are the protection of minority shareholders and the high degree of cross-ownership between family firms. Turkey scores 3.9 out of seven for the protection of minority shareholders’ interests in the World Economic Forum’s 2009-2010 Global Competitiveness Report – placing it 98th out of 133 economies.
“More regulatory safeguards are needed in Turkey to protect minority rights,” says Erkan Savran, head of research at AK Securities. In addition, the boards of Turkey’s large family-owned businesses continue to consist largely of family members.
“We often don’t know if ‘independent’ board members are in fact selected from an independent pool,” says Botan Berker, general manager of Fitch Ratings Turkey.
But the most intractable challenge for companies that seek a level playing field is the size of the black economy. Having to compete against unregistered enterprises – which account for approximately 44 per cent of Turkey’s employed labour force – remains a chief source of complaint for companies that pay their taxes.
“Unfair competition persists in Turkey when I, as a company, am paying taxes and the social security contributions of my employees, but the competition is not,” says Baturalp Candemir, chief economist of EFG Istanbul Securities.
Despite the ruling Justice and Development party’s (AKP) initiative to cut employers’ social security premium payments by 5 per cent in 2008, more than 40 per cent of gross salaries still go to the government.
The majority of unregistered businesses therefore still have insufficient incentive to register with the tax authorities.
“Turkey should focus on solving bureaucratic problems and initiate more reforms in the employment market, including reducing labour costs and increasing labour market flexibility,” according to Hakan Aklar, chief economist of AK Securities.
This is not to deny the progress that Turkey has made over recent years in improving its corporate governance profile. The adoption of international standards in accounting and auditing has been particularly notable.
“We have definitely seen progress in disclosure and transparency, particularly among listed companies, although small unlisted firms are lagging behind,” says Tayfun Bayazit, chairman of Yapi Kredi Bank and chairman of the board for the Corporate Governance Association of Turkey.
The level of awareness among Turkey’s top companies of the benefits of adopting more stringent corporate governance standards has grown meanwhile.
“Turkey is experiencing a positive evolution towards corporate governance. Leading companies are using it as a tool to increase their value and ensure the sustainability of their business,” says Mr Bayazit.
He adds that it also helps companies gain better access to finance, while placing them on a solid footing should they seek to acquire other entities.
The growing awareness about corporate governance issues among Turkey’s companies has, to some extent, been reflected in the Istanbul Stock Exchange’s (ISE) Corporate Governance Index, which was launched in late August 2007.
Whereas 25 companies have qualified for the index today, fewer than 15 companies cut the mustard prior to 2009. The fact that about 9 per cent of the 275 companies listed on the ISE have registered a sufficiently high corporate governance score (six out of 10 or above) to be included in the index is noteworthy, however.
“This does not mean that the performance of listed companies is bad, although it does reflect that many such entities are not, as yet, giving particular importance to corporate governance,” says Mr Candemir.
More significantly, corporate governance standards are likely to receive an essential boost with the eventual passage through parliament of Turkey’s draft commercial code.
“This has been on the agenda for more than two years and its adoption would greatly strengthen legal requirements related to governance,” says Ece Güner, managing partner of Güner Law Office.
“It is also likely to increase the protection of minority shareholders and improve transparency levels.” In addition to corporate transparency, the commercial code’s primary pillars are fairness, accountability and responsibility.
But a swift overhaul of corporate governance practices is unlikely in the short term. The adoption of the commercial code is likely to be phased in gradually.
“Implementation takes time. Small and medium sized enterprises are less willing to support full transparency in their auditing and accounting, as they fear this may affect their competitiveness,” says Mustafa Alper, secretary-general of Turkey’s International Investors Association.
The significance of such resistance derives from the fact that more than 90 per cent of Turkey’s companies are small and medium sized. Yet, precisely such companies are being targeted by the draft law.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2010. You may share using our article tools. Please don't cut articles from FT.com and redistribute by email or post to the web.
