Corporate Governance Developments In Washington


更新时间:2009/12/07 阅读次数:79

Thomas Quaadman is the Executive Director for Financial Reporting Policy and Investor Opportunity with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce's Center for Capital Market Competitiveness .

Over the past several weeks, the debate on financial regulatory reform has intensified and as a result there have been a number of important developments to update everyone on.

SEC Happenings

As we all know the Securities and Exchange Commission has been engaged in a rule making regarding proxy access rules. While the comment period was only open for 60 days, the SEC received a large volume of letters expressing many concerns and raising several issues related to this proposal. In fact, a cursory review of the SEC's website shows that they are still posting new comment letters as they are received and that SEC Commissioners and Staff are engaged in meetings with many people and organizations representing diverse viewpoints.

Because this debate is still ongoing and due to the volume of input that it has received, the SEC announced in early October that it would not take up a final consideration of proxy access until early next year, probably sometime in February. Therefore, any potential changes to proxy access will not be effective until the 2011 proxy season at the earliest. One of the reasons for delay is concern that the SEC's authority to engage in proxy-access rulemaking will be challenged in the courts.

Additionally, the SEC has been engaged in rulemaking on increased proxy disclosures and solicitation enhancements. The comment period closed on September 15, and it is expected that the SEC will finalize the rule making in early December so the new rules will be effective for the 2010 proxy season.

Waters Amendment to the Investor Protection Act

Representative Barney Frank (D-MA), chair of the House Financial Services Committee, has publicly stated that he will not take up corporate governance legislation until the Committee has completed its work on financial regulatory reform, which would be in early 2010. The effort in the House is being spearheaded by Representatives Gary Peters (D-Mich.) and John Campbell (R-Calif.).

However, because of concerns related to legal challenges that may dispute the SEC's authority to issue proxy access rules, Representative Maxine Waters (D-Calif.) offered a clarifying amendment to the Investor Protection Act (H.R. 3817). The Water's Amendment simply states that the SEC has the authority to issue rules on shareholder's access to the company proxy if it chooses to do so. This amendment does not direct the SEC to take any action, rather it just elucidates that the SEC has the power to act if it wishes too.

The Water's Amendment passed the House Financial Services Committee by a vote of 39-30 on November 4. Floor consideration of the Investor Protection Act is expected to take place in December. Despite the passage of the Waters Amendment, the House Financial Services Committee is expected to take up the Peters-Campbell effort early next year.

The Dodd Bill

On November 10, Senator Christopher Dodd (D-Conn.), chair of the Senate Banking Committee, released a discussion draft of his version of financial regulatory reform legislation. The Dodd announcement compliments the release of proposals by the White House and Representative Barney Frank earlier this year. The markup of the Dodd bill is expected to start before Thanksgiving with the Banking Committee should complete consideration before Christmas. Full Senate consideration is not anticipated until next year, and it may take months for the House and Senate financial regulatory packages to be reconciled and a final proposal ready for passage.

The Dodd bill contains a series of corporate governance provisions, many of which are modified versions of proposals contained in the Shareholder Bill of Rights proposed by Senator Charles Schumer (D-NY) earlier this year. The Dodd bill includes:

Majority Voting - The Dodd bill mandates that uncontested directors must be elected by a majority. An uncontested director who receives less than a majority vote must submit his resignation to the Board. The Board may refuse to accept the resignation with a public explanation. The Schumer bill did not allow for the resignation to be rejected.

Proxy Access - Within 180 days of the Dodd bill becoming law the SEC must issue proxy access rules. The Dodd bill does not include thresholds as the Schumer bill does.

Leadership Disclosures - Rejecting the provisions of the Schumer bill that mandated the separation of the Chairman and CEO positions, the Dodd bill requires the disclosure of the leadership structure and an explanation of why that structure is being used. The Dodd bill is similar to the disclosure regime contained in the SEC proposed proxy disclosure and solicitation enhancements rule.

Staggered Board - The Dodd bill prohibits staggering the terms of directors, unless specifically authorized by a vote of the Shareholders.

These four provisions would be applicable to all public companies and a failure to comply with these legal requirements would also be considered a violation of exchange listing rules. The Dodd bill also gives the SEC explicit authority to exempt companies from any or all of these requirements based upon the size of the issuer and other criteria the SEC deems important.

The Dodd bill also includes a number of requirements on executive compensation and governance, applicable to public companies, but without any opt-out authority for the SEC. These provisions include:

Say on Pay - Non-binding advisory shareholder vote on executive compensation.

Golden Parachutes - Shareholder votes on golden parachute polices for issuers.

Compensation Committees - Compensation committees must be independent and can employ their own consultants and legal counsel. Requirements regarding the independence of the committee and the consultant will largely be left up to SEC rule making.

Claw backs - The Dodd bill also mandates issuers to develop policies for claw backs of incentive based compensation if the company must issue restatements of financial reports related to material non compliance with securities laws.

Finally, the Dodd bill also includes a series of governance provisions for financial institutions and those that are determined to be systemically important by the newly proposed Agency for Financial Stability ("AFS," the Systemic Risk Regulator) and the proposed consolidated banking regulator, the Financial Institutions Regulatory Administration ("FIRA"). These provisions include:

Risk Management Committees - Systemically important financial institutions will be required to form committees to manage risk and the AFS will determine the independence requirements of these committees. The Schumer bill had mandated risk-management committees for all public companies.

Compensation - FIRA may restrict the payment of compensation for senior executive officers. Additionally, excessive compensation may lead to higher capital requirements.

Director Liability - Directors will not be liable, if the directors acquiesce to the FDIC being appointed as a receiver in the instance that resolution authority is exercised to wind down a firm.

This represents the current state of play. The next several weeks will be crucial as the House attempts to put the finishing touches on its work and the Senate begins its undertaking in earnest.