Greed hinders good corporate governance


更新时间:2009/05/22 阅读次数:394

By Allen M. Choruma

As we focus on socio-economic and political transformation in Zimbabwe after the global political settlement, there is need for transparency and accountability in the manner in which we govern ourselves at both national and corporate level.

Corruption, corporate scandals and failures governance, that is national and corporate governance, have become a very topical subject in Zimbabwe. Most of these high profile cases of corruption and corporate scandals that we read in the media hinge on the lapse or failure by national and corporate leaders to observe principles of good governance.

The pillars of good governance rest on transparency and accountability. Good governance is about maintaining transparency and accountability in the conduct of business.

Self aggrandisement is one cancer that threatens to destroy the fabric of national and corporate governance. Corruption in leadership seems to continuously surface its ugly head, compromising the gains that are made in the economy.

We have all the seen the headlines in the various national print media: "Minister named in scandal; Ministers accused of looting farm equipment; Tender procedures flouted; Board chairperson accused of bribery; Director commandeers company vehicle; CEO arrested on fraud," and so on.

The level of greed and self aggrandisement in Zimbabwe has reached alarming levels to an extent that His Excellency, President Robert Mugabe, has openly castigated some senior party and Government officials who were abusing their authority to amass property and wealth and stressed that such leaders should be weeded out from public office.

The President in the past has said no to corruption, abuse of power, self aggrandisement and other forms of unethical practices. "Tagarwa neiko (what has possessed us)?" His Excellency publicly lamented recently.

Corruption has not only surfaced its ugly head in the public sectors, it has also spread its tentacles into the private sector. The Anti Corruption Commission has a lot on its plate.

Tone at the Top

National governance sets the tone at the top. Tone at the top means continued and repeated emphasis, followed by commensurate behaviour, by Government ministers and other top officials, on the importance of good governance to both our public and private sectors. Tone at the top means Government ministers and top officials should lead by example by adherence to good ethical standards.

Tone at the top has an overwhelming influence on corporate governance. Good corporate governance can only thrive in an environment where both the public and private sectors follow and foster a culture of responsible ethical behaviour. There is a relationship between national and corporate governance. The latter heavily depends on the former. The sustainability of our economy and the success of our corporate entities (which create wealth and employment) depends on this relationship.

Government Ministers

As the President has highlighted in the past, Government ministers and public office bearers should lead by example. They should set the tone for good governance by upholding high ethical standards themselves. Government ministers are responsible for formulation and implementation of national social, political and macroeconomic policies and they also have statutory oversight functions over strategic state enterprises and other public institutions.

As such ministers have an onerous responsibility to be the torch bearers of good governance. When some of these people who are supposed to be national leaders and harbingers of good governance are repeatedly found on the wrong side of the law, it sends negative messages to the entire country.

Company directors

Recent corporate failures and scandals in Zimbabwe have shown that corruption is a big issue in our economy. Investors entrust their assets to company management and expect company directors to oversee management so that their investments can be protected. Instead some of these people entrusted by investors have turned into thieves and have looted shareholder investments. In addition some company directors and executives have garnered substantial compensation packages for themselves even as their companies face collapse. These corporate scandals have caused a lot of public anger at the failure of our governance systems to protect investor interests. The result has been the breakdown of public trust, a decline of confidence in the integrity of our financial and capital markets and overall loss of confidence in the manner in which our corporations are governed.

Furthermore some professional advisors to companies such as lawyers, auditors, consultants in various fields have also compromised good corporate governance by failing to provide balanced and independent advice and professional judgement to protect business interests.

Tough measures

This is the time to take tough measures to promote good governance in both public and private sectors. We can talk and preach about good governance at conferences but if we do not address and weed out corruption our efforts will be futile. Corruption will derail our efforts to promote good governance. People have called for enactment of tough legislation to deal with corruption. However, it has often been said that no nation can legislate against corruption. Tough legislation may be put in place but it may not stop graft. Legislation does not fully address issues of corporation. My personal view is that we need to pursue a number of initiatives simultaneously. Tough laws on their own will not usher good governance.

Ethics

Ethics is a central nervous system for good governance. Every organisation should be guided by good business ethics as characterised by the following attributes: Discipline, Transparency, Independence, Accountability, Responsibility, Fairness, and Respect.

These attributes are cornerstones of good business ethics and should be embedded in the day-to-day operations of all organisations. This will go a long way in preventing major financial debacles, concluded professor Sulcas in his article.

Corporate governance has undoubtedly improved in Zimbabwe over the last five years. As a nation we have made significant progress in creating awareness and raising corporate governance standards in all sectors of our economy.

Most organisations in Zimbabwe can now boast of having basic corporate governance structures such as a board of directors and board committees. Some organisations have even gone steps further by voluntarily adopting best international practices of good corporate governance as enshrined in international corporate governance codes.

Embracing reform

Although nationally we have made significant strides in embracing corporate governance reforms enshrined in international corporate governance codes, as a nation we still lag behind in many respects. Good governance should not be a tick box approach. It’s ethics based. Corporate governance should be driven by principles as opposed to instruction. As Mervin King puts it: "principle is better than instruction". What this means is that directors should adopt a "principles-based governance approach". A principles-based governance approach is about ethics and values; self introspection; voluntary compliance; self regulation and voluntary application of best practice principles.

What this means is that we should not just talk of corruption and end there. Rhetoric will not address the threats to good governance. We need a balanced approach that involves the following: legislation and regulation, active government participation (right tone at the top), promotion of self regulation governance mechanisms such as corporate governance codes, massive campaigns on ethics, strengthen governance through various national bodies.

Last, but not least, we need to prosecute cases of corruption. We need to strengthen law enforcement and the judiciary system to ensure compliance with our laws and regulations. We also need to strengthen and capacitate the institutions that we have created to fight corruption such as the Anti Corruption Commission. If we don’t do this, good governance may remain an illusion in Zimbabwe.