|
Strengthening corporate governance has always been an important and necessary component of the restructuring and recapitalization plans of all major banks in China. To date, listed Chinese banks have already established a governance structure, with the presence of an audit committee overseeing external financial reporting, risk management and internal controls. Similar to their counterparts in the West, a lot of the local banks, especially those preparing for listings on overseas exchanges, are not content with where they are, and are still striving to improve the effectiveness of their audit committees. Ernst & Young recently completed the second survey of bank audit committee practices, for 2004, on the 50 largest banks and capital markets firms headquartered in North America (30 participated representing a response rate of 60 per cent). The key findings, set out below, may be a useful reference for banks in China in assessing their current practices. Composition On the whole, the average size of audit committees did not change significantly last year. Consistent with our 2003 survey, the most common number of board members serving on the audit committee was five. Financial experts are well represented on audit committees, significantly exceeding the minimum requirement. Nearly 70 per cent of survey respondents had at least two financial experts on their audit committees, and more than 20 per cent had four or more. Corporate governance around audit committee member selection appeared strong. Most institutions (87 per cent) used either a nominating committee or their corporate governance committee to identify new members. Almost all respondents indicated their nomination process had not changed last year. Restrictions and rotation Most institutions (73 per cent) reported they placed restrictions on the number of other boards on which their members were allowed to sit. This was a large increase from 2003, when 40 per cent of respondents indicated they had such restrictions. Institutions that impose such restrictions typically allowed their audit committee members to sit on a maximum of two or three other boards. Nearly 90 per cent of audit committees did not have a rotation or term limit policy in place for their members. Orientation and education Ninety per cent of institutions provided orientation to new audit committee members, up from 75 per cent in the 2003's survey. Somewhat surprising was the fact less than half of institutions offered formal continuing education programmes to audit committee members, and 38 per cent of those respondents implemented such programmes last year. Most respondents were confident about the quality of their programmes: 92 per cent of respondents felt both orientation and continuing education of audit committee members at their institutions were either adequate or excellent. Of those institutions with continuing education processes in place, more than half (54 per cent) reported their audit committee members devoted 10 hours or more per year to education. To fulfil their continuing education needs, the majority of institutions used a combination of approaches including internal resources (96 per cent), mail-out materials (89 per cent), external resources (63 per cent) and classroom sessions (15 per cent). Those who used external sources cited external auditors (67 per cent) and legal counsel (40 per cent) as their primary sources. The top areas in which audit committees felt additional education would be valuable were derivatives and financial instruments, accounting and financial reporting developments, and regulatory issues. Meetings, agenda and workload Overall, the number of audit committee meetings held last year did not change significantly from our prior survey, although meetings generally lasted longer. The numbers ranged from four to eight meetings per year, and 83 per cent of respondents indicated the number of full-scope meetings held last year had not changed at all over 2003. More than two-thirds of respondents' audit committees hold six or more full-scope meetings each year. Most respondents (83 per cent) also hold specific-scope meetings; 27 per cent of those indicated the number increased last year, while only 4 per cent indicated a decrease. Sixty percent of all respondents held three or more specific-scope meetings last year. Meetings were, however, getting longer. Last year, 40 per cent of respondents indicated the average length of meetings had increased, and 60 per cent of respondents indicated meetings were three hours or longer. That was up significantly from 2003, when only 31 per cent of institutions indicated that meetings lasted three hours or more. Fifty-five per cent of respondents indicated their audit committee members spend between 20 and 50 hours per year fulfilling their responsibilities, while the remaining 45 per cent reported members spend in excess of 50 hours annually. Considering that 83 per cent of respondents indicated their audit committee members also sat on other board committees, directors who serve on audit committees of large financial institutions spent significant amounts of time fulfilling their board-level responsibilities. Interactions Most boards use four or five board-level committees. Eighty-seven per cent of respondents have at least four committees reporting to the board, a slight increase from 79 per cent in 2003. Nearly all institutions have corporate governance or nomination committees. Somewhat surprising, especially considering the number of large institutions participating in the survey, is a relatively low number (37 per cent) of respondents have a separate risk committee. While there is extensive interaction between committees, 81 per cent of respondents indicate interactions did not change significantly last year. The most common forms of interaction between committees remain cross-membership at committee meetings (83 per cent) and review of information provided by other committees (63 per cent). Most audit committees meet eight times a year with the chief financial officer, the principal accounting officer, internal audit and external audit these last two accounting for the greatest increase (30 per cent) in interaction over 2004. Internal audit was ranked as a top resource for advice and counsel to the audit committee on issues by all respondents. The position to which internal audit reports administratively varies among respondents, the chief executive officer being the most common (28 per cent). Last year, 93 per cent of respondents' audit committees evaluated the performance of internal audit, up from 81 per cent in 2003. All respondents' audit committees are involved in evaluating their institution's external auditors, an increase from 77 per cent in 2003. Nearly two-thirds of audit committees evaluate external auditors jointly with management rather than independently. External auditors and the institutions' CFOs were both identified as a resource to audit committees by 87 per cent of respondents. Most audit committees try to obtain their primary counsel and advice internally: 92 per cent of respondents sought external advice or counsel on issues three times or fewer last year. Pre-approval policies Respondents reported a variety of pre-approval policies. The most common policy was a requirement for full-committee approval of services. All respondents felt their processes effectively ensured compliance with their institutions' pre-approval policies. The majority of audit committees (63 per cent) were not involved in external audit-fee negotiations, but instead approved fees negotiated by management. Evaluation Self-review is by far the most common form of audit committee evaluation. Almost all respondents perform periodic performance self-assessment, and 96 per cent of those perform it annually (the remaining 4 per cent perform it semi-annually). This is a significant increase from 2003, when only 58 per cent of respondents indicated their audit committees performed self-assessments. Enterprise risks Financial reporting, SOX 404, regulatory issues and compliance of systems and processes are the key risks perceived by most audit committees. Audit committees continue relying most on reports from management and dialogues in meetings in discharging their responsibilities. Respondents specified numerous major areas they recently improved, or are in the process of improving, to enhance the effectiveness of their audit committees. While no common themes emerged, areas for improvement cited included better orientation of new members, improving written materials distributed prior to meetings, strengthening education for audit committee members, greater co-ordination among committees, improving audit committee self-evaluation processes, and recruiting and selecting new audit committee members based on financial and corporate governance expertise. The ways different banks undertake the aforementioned initiatives illustrate that a forceful, continuous improvement process is of fundamental importance to improving corporate governance.
(China Daily 06/27/2005 page5) |
|||||
