New York's State Common Retirement Fund alleged the WoldCom board of directors had been "utterly derelict in carrying out its most basic functions" providing "no internal checks and balances on WorldCom management" and was "completely beholden to management." More importantly, the Fund insisted that directors pay a significant portion of the settlement. In an unprecedented move, 10 former directors agreed to pay $54 million, including $18 million out of their own pockets.
The news came on the same day a preliminary settlement was announced requiring 10 former Enron Corp. board members to pay $13 million of their own money to resolve an investor lawsuit over the energy giant's 2001 meltdown. The $13 million payout by former board members at Enron would be part of a larger $168 million settlement with the Regents of University of California, who were the lead plaintiffs on a class action lawsuit.
If anything will make directors think twice about dereliction of duties, this should do it. It “will likely have a jarring effect on anyone serving, or considering serving, on the board of a public company.” Directors who were paid about $35,000 a year are now liable to pay out millions. (Commentary: Ex-WorldCom Directors Agree to $54 Million Settlement by Bruce Carton, Executive Director, Securities Class Action Services, ISS Friday Report, 1/7/05)
The amount is said to total 20% of the directors' aggregate net worth, not counting their primary residences, retirement accounts and certain joint marital assets. But Dan Ackman, writing for Forbes.com, says “Of course, if you exclude primary residences, retirement accounts and certain joint marital assets, most people, even fairly well-to-do people don't have much of a net worth at all, so taking those categories out of the mix would seem to render the 20% figure fairly meaningless.”
“If company directors perceive the WorldCom settlement as a warning, then it's a warning,” according to Ackman but class action suits recover only a pittance of what has been lost. Indictments for fraud have also leveled off. “Despite WorldCom and Enron all the whining and crying about Sarbanes-Oxley, the numbers underneath seem to show that the real story is business as usual.” (Accounting For The WorldCom Deal, 1/6/05)
The consensus, however, seems to be that it will have an impact. Charles Elson, director of the Center for Corporate Governance at the University of Delaware said, "directors will certainly seek to avoid any conflicts of interests like the plague. But will anybody want to serve on a board? That's the question." Roger Raber, president and CEO of the National Association of Corporate Directors said, "WorldCom was an egregious example, but now, if something goes wrong anywhere else, they'll go after the directors. That's a terrible precedent to set." (WorldCom settlement could have long-reaching effect on corporate boards, Canada.com, 1/9/05)
Yet, what is so terrible about holding directors personally accountable for their actions? Why should insurance companies pay for what the New York's State Common Retirement Fund characterized as utter dereliction of duties? "If directors want to play cheerleader, there's a price to pay," warns Patrick McGurn, special counsel to Institutional Shareholder Services. “Being a director isn't what it used to be. But maybe, at last, it's what it should be, wrote Daniel Kadlec for Time Magazine. (A Wake-Up Call For Directors, 1/17/05)
Ten former Enron directors also agreed to pay $13 million of a $168 million settlement from their own assets to settle litigation brought by shareholders whose investments were wiped out after the failed U.S. energy giant's 2001 bankruptcy filing. In the Enron case, $60 billion of shareholder valuee wiped out. The out-of-pocket settlement by directors equaled 10% of their pretax profit from Enron stock sales. According to Lucian Bebchuk, a professor at Harvard Law School and co-author of Pay Without Performance, "the settlement hardly heralds a new era in which directors who fail to act in shareholders' interests pay the price. If even Enron's board members are treated this gently, then other corporate directors can rest easy." (see NYTimes, 1/17/05, What's $13 Million Among Friends?)
