The U.S. Chamber of Commerce stepped up its backlash against recent and proposed corporate governance reforms by filing a friend-of-the-court brief in support of Siebel Systems, which is fighting accusations by the SEC that it violated Regulation Fair Disclosure (FD). "At its essence, Regulation FD requires corporate executives either to share their material business information with no one, so as to avoid triggering the disclosure requirement, or to share it with everyone," the Chamber wrote. "In either case, Regulation FD impermissibly violates corporate executives' right to freedom of expression and association." that "in punishing companies for selectively disclosing 'material and nonpublic' information, Regulation FD impairs fundamental First Amendment values."
Last June the SEC alleged that Siebel chief financial officer Kenneth Goldman disclosed material nonpublic information during two private events he attended with former investor relations director Mark Hanson on April 30, 2003, in New York: a one-on-one meeting with an institutional investor and an invitation-only dinner hosted by Morgan Stanley.
This is the second time Siebel allegedly violated Regulation FD. In November 2002 the SEC issued a cease-and-desist order and imposed a $250,000 civil penalty against the company for statements made at an invitation-only conference sponsored by Goldman Sachs.
The Chamber also opposes the SEC's proposed proxy access rule and is challenging the SEC's authority to require that 75% of mutual-fund directors be independent. (Chamber of Commerce Supports Challenge to SEC 'Fair Disclosure' Rule, FindLaw.com, 1/28/05)
