SEC Should Look to Europe


更新时间:2004/11/23 阅读次数:342

David F. Morrison's  editorial in the August issue of Insights:The Corporate and Securities Law Advisor reminds us that "In business, if not in our politics, America should have the open-mindedness to realize that the actions we take will have effects outside our borders, and that there are lessons to be learned from experience other than our own." In "Shareholder Proxy Access -- America Should Not Go It Alone Again," Morrison joins those asking the SEC to delay its rule on shareholder access to the proxy for the nominating directors. However, Morrison's plea is not for a perpetual delay, like the BRT, but is an intelligent call to study "real world experience in other countries, the optimal balance between that process, shareholder voting rules (majority versus plurality voting) and proxy access."

Morrison notes recent changes - 1) stock exchange listing standards requiring a nominating committee composed entirely of independent directors and 2) SEC rules that require shareholders to be informed of the criteria the nominating committee uses to select candidates. "Reports are that nominating committees and shareholders are communicating, that there is a new dialogue and that the old system of the CEO dominated nomination process has been changed for good." (Of course, one reason for this is the pending access rule.)

Unlike critics of shareholder access, Morrison suggests take a at Europe. The director nomination process in the US now assures a nomination process controlled by independent directors. (Although, as we have often seen, independence doesn't preclude the CEO's college roomates or golfing buddies.) In some European countries nominating committees are recommended, but neither the Combined Code in the United Kingdom, nor the Bouton report in France, recommend full independence. "The Bouton report in fact recommends that the CEO be actively involved in the work of the nominating committee."

Plurality vs. Majority Voting.
Grundfest, Veasey and Millstein made quite a splash by recommending that instead of access to the proxy, directors should be elected by majority vote and that withhold votes should be counted as no votes. The UK has long had this approach. France, Germany and various other European jurisdictions are no different. "In each of the three countries, shareholders can vote for or against a nominee, and election requires that the yes votes outnumber the no votes."

Proxy Access. Proxy access

  • "In the UK, 100 or more shareholders holding shares representing on average GBP 100 of paid in capital, or shareholders with 5 percent or more of the voting rights, can require a company to circulate a resolution for discussion at a shareholders' meeting.
  • In France, shareholders holding a specified percentage of shares (which is calculated on a degressive scale and would approximate 1.4 percent of the share capital of a company with Euro 100 million of share capital) and certain qualified shareholders associations that have held their shares in registered form for two years and who hold 1 percent or more of the shares can send proposals to the board which must be included in the resolutions submitted to shareholder vote.
  • In Germany, shareholders can submit counter proposals to the company until two weeks before the date of the annual meeting.

In each of the three countries the shareholder proposals can include a nominee for a director."

Morrison notes that "it is astounding that, in the avalanche of commentary and discussion that has been triggered by the proxy access proposal, the experience in other countries is given such short shrift," being mentioned only twice during the full day of roundtable discussions.

Clearly, our adventure in Iraq must give us pause. Perhaps it is better to listen closely to our allies. If we can set similar standards, business, and perhaps politics, can be run more smoothly.