CalPERS fails disclose the management and advisory fees it pays to private equity and hedge funds. They're being sued by the California First Amendment Coalition (a group of news organizations). Two years ago, CalPERS resisted a similar call for transparency but later settled and now discloses performance results for its 300-plus private equity funds quarterly.
The Wall Street Journal editorializes that what's been revealed seem to involve cronyism:
- Yucaipa Companies. Head, Ron Burkle, has been a generous political donor to two board members -- Willie Brown, and Phil Angelides. Another board member, Sidney Abrams, who has done actuarial consulting for Mr. Burkle. Returns have been negative.
- Grove Street Advisors. Fund managers have contributed to Angelides and California Comptroller Steve Westly. Returns are negative.
- Premier Pacific Vineyards. Co-chief executive, Richard Wollack, an Angelides supporter. Investments are under water.
- Progress Investment Management, a Willie Brown supporter with negative returns.
- CIM California Urban Real Estate Fund. Kurato Shimada, a board member, took two years off to work for the marketing firm and lobbied board members to invest $125 million in opposition to staff advice. After pocketing his placement fees, Shimada rejoined the board. WSJ reports that returns have been triple-digit positive.
WSJ argues that, "Perhaps all of these investments only look like conflicts of interest and they are all worthy on their merits...Given that most of these investments have so far been dogs, the question of fees is even more relevant." (Calpers and Cronyism, WSJ, 10/18/04) CalPERS should follow there own good corporate governance advice and fully disclose. Additionally, we need to close the revolving door and tighten campaign funding laws to discourage what too closely appears as pay to play.
