Disney Moves For No-Action


更新时间:2004/11/23 阅读次数:172

Walt Disney Co. (DIS) has notified the SEC it intends to exclude the shareholder resolution to allow shareholder nominees on thie proxy from its 2005 ballot, arguing the proponents are out of legal bounds, according to a report in WSJ ( Disney Seeks To Thwart Pension-Fund Bid For Vote On Dir., 10/28/04)

"The company respectfully requests the staff of the division of corporation finance of the commission confirm that it will not recommend enforcement action to the commission if the company excludes the proposal from its 2005 proxy materials," a Wachtell lawyer wrote, in the so-called no-action letter to the division.

In the past, SEC lawyers have shown a willingness to allow such non-binding resolutions, as long as they are precisely drafted to mirror the agency's original proposal. But according to Disney, the resolution doesn't precisely follow the SEC's original rule proposal. For one thing, those who subitted the resolution don't quite hold 1% of Disney's shares.

Among other arguments, Disney makes a seemingly hyper-technical point in a footnote, noting that the SEC has been sympathetic to such arguments in the past. In the footnote, Disney notes that the SEC's rule proposal says shareholders holding 5% for "at least" two years would be eligible to submit a director nomination, but the pension resolution calls for a nomination from shareholders holding 5% for "more than" two years.

"As a result, the proposal by the sponsors would deprive those who hold the requisite number of shares of company common stock for exactly two years to be a nominating shareholder, contrary to the shareholder nomination procedure in the commission's proposed rules, and as a result, the proposal is properly omitted," Disney's lawyer wrote in the footnote.

The footnote cites a decision earlier this year by the staff of the SEC blocking a similar proposal at Qwest Communications International Inc.'s (Q) annual meeting. As submitted to Qwest, the non-binding resolution urged the board to allow investors holding "at least 5%" of the stock to float a nominee in the company's proxy materials. But the company argued - and the SEC agreed - that, in order to be a fitting ballot resolution, qualified shareholders had to own "greater than 5%" in line with the exact language of its proposed rule.

The four funds -- CalPERS, the New York State Common Retirement Fund, AFSCME Pension Funds, and the Illinois State board of Investment -- should hold firm on Disney and should widen their net to others as well.