CalPERS, the New York State Common Retirement Fund, the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees Pension Funds (AFSCME), and the Illinois State Board of Investment, which own more than 18 million shares of Disney stock, filed a shareholder proposal with the SEC to give shareowners the right to nominate directors at Walt Disney. It calls for a group of shareholders to be able to nominate up to two directors on Disney's 11-member board and have them included on the company's proxy. If it receives a majority of votes in 2005, they could nominate the two directors for the 2006 annual meeting.
The shareholder proposal filed at Disney is similar to one put forth by AFSCME and other public pension funds last year at Marsh McLennan, following news of scandals at its Putnam subsidiary. The funds withdrew the proposal after Marsh McLennan nominated Zachory Carter, a former federal prosecutor to its board. (see The Disneyland Report, Four Public Pension Funds File Shareowner Resolution to Name Disney Directors)
A copy of the Disney shareholder proposal follows:
RESOLVED, that shareholders of The Walt Disney Company ("Disney") ask that Disney become subject to the shareholder right of access to the company proxy statement afforded in the SEC's proposed Rule 14a-11 (the "Rule"), which would (a) allow a shareholder or group that has held over 5% of Disney's outstanding common shares for over two years ("Nominating Shareholder") to nominate up to a specified number of candidates ("Nominees") who are independent from both the Nominating Shareholder and Disney for election to Disney's board of directors and (b) require Disney to allow shareholders to vote for Nominees on Disney's proxy card and to make certain disclosures regarding Nominees in Disney's proxy statement.
In the case of Disney, the Rule would allow a Nominating Shareholder to nominate up to two Nominees, because Disney's board currently has 11 members. However, Disney's bylaws set the board size as a range from nine to 21. In the event that Disney's board is expanded to 20 or more directors, the Rule would allow nomination of up to three Nominees.
SUPPORTING STATEMENT
Currently, the process for nominating and electing directors is a closed system, with incumbent boards determining whom to nominate and shareholders ratifying those choices through their proxy ballots. Although shareholders may use their own proxy materials to advance director candidacies, the expense and difficulty of doing so means that such challenges are rare outside the hostile takeover context.
The SEC has proposed to provide shareholders with the opportunity to nominate director candidates to appear in the company proxy statement under certain circumstances. One circumstance is when holders of a majority of shares voting approve a shareholder proposal asking that the company provide such shareholder access. The proponents of this proposal do not own 1% of Disney's stock. Thus, adoption of this proposal would not automatically lead to the inclusion of candidates nominated by 5% of Disney's shareholders.
We believe that Disney's corporate governance will benefit if shareholders are empowered to nominate director candidates, and that now is an appropriate time to move in the direction of greater accountability to shareholders. Last year, holders of 45% of shares withheld their votes from CEO Michael Eisner for his reelection to Disney's board in a protest against Disney's unsatisfactory performance and the lack of independent leadership on the part of Disney's board. Subsequently, the board separated the positions of CEO and Chairman, and more recently, Mr. Eisner announced he would step down from his position as CEO, but not until 2006.
In our opinion, giving shareholders the ability to nominate director candidates on Disney's proxy statement will make Disney's board more responsive to shareholder interests. Such responsiveness is especially important now, in the context of a search for Mr. Eisner's successor. We also believe that allowing shareholders access to Disney's proxy materials may help strengthen the board's monitoring ability.
We urge shareholders to vote for this proposal.
It will be interesting to see what happens. Unfortunately, the SEC has interpreted Rule 14a-(8)(i)(8) to exclude proposals, which relate to an election for membership on the Company's Board of Directors. Even if the SEC finally moves on its Security Holder Director Nominations, S7-19-03 rulemaking, the pension funds admit they don't hold a large enough percentage of the stock to qualify their proposal. Still, the funds are pushing in the right direction. Disney could always wake to the need to listen to its shareholders. Apria adopted changes necessary to allow shareholders to place board nominees on the proxy. As long as shareholders push back, there is hope for increasing corporate accountability.
