The Smell of Gunpowder in the Air


更新时间:2004/04/02 阅读次数:158

Rarely do I turn to The Conference Board’s publication “Across the Board” for the latest insights into democratic corporate governance. However, James Krohe Jr.’s “The Battle for Corporate Power” is one of the best summaries I have seen in any recent publication. From the opening paragraphs, it is apparent that he is not holding back in describing the movement.

The large, publicly owned corporation is, nominally, a representative democracy. But power in most corporations lies everywhere but in the hands of the people. For decades, the shareholders of big U.S. companies have resembled the pre-Revolutionary American colonists, who labored under an indifferent ruling class that looted the people's wealth and that left them few lawful means of redress. Today, citizen shareholders vote for referenda that company leaders ignore; they are represented by people whom they have no say in choosing.

Unhappy shareholders, like the colonists, have two choices. One is to simply invest their money somewhere else — the shareholder equivalent of going into exile. The other is to rebel in the hope of taking control. Few shareholders in the past have had the stomach for such a fight. But open a window on Wall Street today, and you can smell gunpowder in the air.

He sees advocates for more democratic corporate governance largely divided into two camps. “Value-seekers” want “to pry out the potential profits that lies not in new products or markets but in unrealized management improvements. The other faction he calls “value-builders.” These shareowners embrace corporate democracy “as a way to bring corporations under control, by committing them to extra-financial values such as diversity, sustainability, and nonviolence. The list of corporate sins is as endless as the human capacity for outrage.”

Krohe then discusses the current SEC proposal to allow shareholders to place their nominees on the corporate proxy in very limited circumstances. Just as civil democracy was improved by expanding the vote to former slaves, then women, and finally to people aged 18-20, the current SEC proposal will not be accepted as final justice.

Krohe quotes me saying, “I doubt if anyone in 1919 was proposing that women should get the vote only in specific townships or jurisdictions where they can demonstrate they've been treated badly, or that in those jurisdictions, they'll get to nominate only one-eighth of their representatives."

Within the article, Nell Minow notes that whatever happens in 2004, the war is far from over. “The core issue for the next five years will be access to the proxy,” Minow insists. “Whatever the outcome,” Krohe concludes, “annual general meetings that used to resemble coronations will become more like big-party political conventions.” Mark Latham’s brands become nascent political parties. Whether they divide along the lines of “value-seekers” and “values builders,” it is still unclear. However, a consensus to shift primacy in the boardroom from CEOs to shareowners appears to be clearly in the wind.