Disney on the Ropes


更新时间:2004/04/02 阅读次数:160

Separating the CEO and the chair was a good move; the trouble is with the occupants. Clearly, after an unprecedented 43% no confidence vote, Michael Eisner should have been shown the door. Although that number makes the 24% no confidence vote earned by George Mitchell look small, it was not.

Shareholders are no longer willing to sidestep the issues. Roy Disney and Stanley Gold indicated, “It is clear from this action that corporate governance is just talk at the Walt Disney Company. We renew our call for substantive change beginning with the immediate commencement of a search for a new CEO and the selection of a truly independent Chairman of the Board."

Sean Harrigan, President of CalPERS stated, “Eisner should go and the Board should get quickly to work on planning for an orderly transition." Cynthia Richson, the corporate governance officer for the Ohio Public Employees Retirement System said, "I'm extremely disappointed with Mitchell. There are questions about his psychological independence, considering his long-standing ties with Eisner." Robert A.G. Monks, Respected governance luminary, commented on the vote, "It would have been a discharge vote at 33 percent. At 43 percent, they shouldn't even take time to blot the ink on the resignation ... He's got to go.”

A spokeswoman Institutional Shareholder Services was quoted as saying, "If the Disney Board believes this is the silver bullet to fix all the problems, they are sort of mistaken. The level of the vote makes it clear that investors have a lot more on their minds than just the splitting of the position." The Council of Institutional Investors stated, "And the most troubling thing of all? The company's response to this extraordinary shareholder proxy revolt trivialized it." Even Charles Elson, director of the University of Delaware's Center for Corporate Governance who I’ve always viewed as a moderate said, "Disney once again seems to be misunderstanding the situation. This is a shuffling of the chairs, not a change."

(Based on Roy Disney and Stanley Gold press release. Contact: Clifford Miller of Shamrock Holdings, 818-973-4297; or Michael Sitrick of Sitrick And Company, 310-788-2850, for Roy Disney and Stanley Gold; or investors, Charlie Koons, or Larry Dennedy, both of MacKenzie Partners, 800-322-2885.)

A Few recent epic votes include:

  • 2003: At AOL Time Warner's annual meeting, 22% of shareholders withhold their votes for board member Steve Case. Case, anticipating the negative vote, resigns beforehand as chairman. Case remains on the board today.
  • 2002: At Lockheed Martin, 28% of shareholders withhold their votes for director Frank Savage in a reelection challenge linked to his role as an Enron director. Savage remains on the board today.
  • 2001: Service Employees International Union and other major investors urge Eastman Kodak shareholders to withhold support from four board members; about 17% of shareholders do so. One of the four directors leaves the board the next year. The other three remain on the board. today.
  • 2001: At mining company Freeport McMoRan Copper & Gold, a challenge led by New York City pension funds causes shareholders to withhold 18% to 25% of votes for a slate of five directors. The next year, in voting on a different set of directors, shareholders withhold nearly 39% of votes. Despite the votes, board membership remains largely unchanged today.