Judge Richard J. Holwell denied a preliminary injunction sought by the MONY Group claiming that Highfields Capital Management's inclusion of a duplicate proxy card in a campaign to defeat a corporate merger violated rules passed pursuant to section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
Holwell said that a bar could be seen as "frustrating the animating spirit that lies at the core" of the rule in question, which is intended to make it easier for shareholders to communicate without having to mount expensive battles. (Dissident's Use of Proxy Card Exempt From Rules, Law.com, 2/14/04. Judge Rules in Favor of Opponents of MONY Takeover, NYTimes, 2/12/04)
