California May Trump SECs Move Toward Democracy


更新时间:2004/03/13 阅读次数:146

California's Secretary of State Kevin Shelley sponsored legislation in California, introduced by Assemblymember Judy Chu that appears to go a step further than the SEC's rulemaking, Security Holder Director Nominations, S7-19-03. AB 2752 would require publicly traded corporations doing business in California to have election procedures meeting specified requirements, such as:
  • Shareholder eligibility: Corporate election procedures would allow shareholders or groups with more than 2% of the company’s stock held for 2 years to nominate directors. This compares with the SEC's proposed requirement of a 5% threshold and without the "triggering" event to stall action.
  • Soliciting support: Companies would be required to make information available to shareholders no less than once per year regarding all individuals or groups interested in soliciting support to nominate candidates for the board. The notifications required by the corporation will better enable shareholder coalitions to form.
  • Deadlines and candidate information: Proxy statements shall include 250 word statements provided by director candidates. The proposed SEC rules require far fewer words and contemplates use of shareholder internet sites to convey information.
  • Candidate limits: Not less than 40% of the total number of directors on the board must be eligible for nomination by shareholders. The SEC proposal limits most companies to 1 or 2 shareholder nominated directors.
  • Nomination process: In order to have a nominee included in a company's proxy statement and proxy card, the nominating shareholder or group must provide specified notice to the company, no later than 80 days before the company mails its proxy material.
  • Allowable restrictions: The procedures may include restrictions to restrict nominees who are not independent or are convicted criminals. "Independent" may need to be further defined but the law would not appear to preclude shareholder from nominating professional "relational investors" or turnaround specialists, unlike the SEC proposal.
  • A company's proxy card shall identify shareholder nominees, and shall present the nominees in an impartial manner. Each candidate must be voted on separately. This provision helps to level the playing field.
  • If a company includes statements in its proxy statement supporting company nominees or opposing shareholder nominee(s), the nominating shareholder or nominating group shall be given the opportunity to include a statement not to exceed 500 words per nominee.
  • Companies would be required to make information regarding the process and deadlines to nominate and elect an individual to the board available on their website and in their annual report.
  • The Secretary of State shall, not later than December 31, 2005, provide access to the corporate election procedures by means of an online database. This provision would seem to require a substantial amount of work the Secretary of State. How would the possible need for an appropriation during California's budget crisis impact the bill's chances of passage?
Further, the bill would require that corporations doing business in California shall implement any shareholder proposal that passes by a majority vote, unless the proposal clearly states it is advisory. If a corporation establishes a means to place an advisory shareholder proposal on the ballot, it shall also establish a means to place shareholder proposals on the ballot that are required be implemented. The bill provides for fines of up to $100,000 dollars a day for every day a proposal is not implemented. Contact Information: Julio Martinez is staffing the bill for Assemblymember Chu. His office number is (916) 319-2049. Willie Guerrero, Assistant Secretary of State, is the contact within Kevin Shelley’s office. Please cc James McRitchie, Publisher of CorpGov.Net.

Letters should be directed to: Assemblywoman Judy Chu, State Capitol Room 2114, Sacramento, CA 95814 and Secretary of State Kevin Shelley, 1500 - 11th Street, Executive Office, Sacramento, CA 95814. The SEC got over 12,000 comments on their rulemaking. I hope Shelley and Chu can handle the mail this bill will generate.