According to a 1/25/04 report by Reuters, business leaders at the World Economic Forum in Davos Switzerland "shunned calls for tougher regulation in the wake of a raft of corporate scandals, saying more rules would prove ineffective and cumbersome." Despite the billions of dollars gone missing from the accounts of Italian food group Parmalat in Europe, from U.S. energy trader Enron, and numerous others, the Davos attendees said a higher sense of moral responsibility at the boardroom level would be more effective than a rules clampdown.
The US introduced stiffer corporate governance rules under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act and in Europe, the Parmalat scandal has intensified calls for regulators to follow suit. "Checking boxes and signing things won't solve integrity problems," said Daniel Vasella, Chief Executive Officer of Swiss drugs firm Novartis. James Schiro, chief executive officer of insurer Zurich Financial Services, said "ethical behaviour cannot be regulated, it cannot be imposed by legislation."
"There have been huge failures in corporate governance," said, Nina Mitz, chief executive of public relations firm Financial Dynamics. "Companies have to be managed better and then the level of transparency has to be improved, and then afterward, this message has to be taken out to the public," she said.
In contrast, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), made up of 30 member countries, including the US, UK and working relationships with more than 70 other countries, unveiled a draft revision of its "Principles of Corporate Governance" that was adopted by member governments in 1999. Although they are non-binding, the principles provide guidance for national legislation and regulation, as well as guidance for stock exchanges. Among the proposals:
- Granting investors the right to nominate company directors, as well as a more forceful role in electing them.
- Providing shareholders with a voice in the compensation policy for board members and executives, and giving them the ability to submit questions to auditors.
- Mandating that institutional investors disclose their overall voting policies and how they manage material conflicts of interest that may affect the way they exercise key ownership functions, such as voting.
- Identifying the need for effective protection of creditor rights and an efficient system for dealing with corporate insolvency.
- Directing rating agencies, brokers and other providers of information that could influence investor decisions to disclose conflicts of interest, and how the conflicts are being managed.
- Mandating board members to be more rigorous in disclosing related party transactions and protecting so-called "whistle blowers" by providing employees with confidential access to a board level contact.
Officials expect to submit a final revised version of the "Principles" to OECD governments for approval at the annual meeting of the group's Council at Ministerial Level on 5/13-14/2004. OECD Invites Comment on Draft Revision of its Corporate Governance Principles.
