Marc Gunther's article, "Calpers Rides Again," in the 12/8/03 edition of Fortune magazine focuses on the growing influence of California Treasurer Phil Angelides and his "controversial new agenda." He sits on the boards of CalPERS and CalSTRS, the 1st and 3rd largest public pension funds in the US. "That concentrates a quarter of a trillion dollars of investing power in a state not known as business-friendly. How that power will be used by the trustees who run Calpers and Calstrs--all Democrats, many with close ties to unions--is an important question."
Traditionally, CalPERS focused on board independence, executive pay, and other corporate governance issues. Recently, though, "Calpers and Calstrs have gone beyond governance into social engineering." Examples of what Gunther terms "social engineering" are:
- Divestment of tobacco stocks, which subsequently rebounded.
- Lobbying US firms that reincorporated overseas to "come home to America," even if that means paying more taxes.
- Steering investments to inner-city businesses.
- Green investing.
Gunther acknowledges that CalPERS' inner-city investments might generate not only direct returns but also indirect benefits because "they curb inequality, reduce the costs of poverty, and create new customers for other companies owned by the fund. Angelides calls this a "double bottom line"--financial returns and social good." As a long-term investor in, essentially, the entire market, CalPERS has an incentive to look at the entire economy. "I don't think many companies can be successful in an unsuccessful economy," Angelides says. Nor can companies thrive, he says, in an economy plagued by environmental woes, health-care costs, or "great divisions between rich and poor that erupt into social tension."
One of the risks of this strategy, according to Gunther, is that such investments "could be turned into payback for campaign contributors." "Who is to decide which company's practices are social or antisocial, good or bad for the overall economy?"
Of course, in this editor's opinion, that role ultimately falls to members of the system and to taxpayers. Members of the system, who work to protect the environment and public health, don't want CalPERS to disregard the environmental record of the companies they invest in and they don't want to encourage California's youth to take up smoking. Taxpayers are probably more concerned with not having to pick up the tab if the "social engineering" investment strategy doesn't pay off. However, many also share the values of public empolyees and the financial risks appear to be minimal.
Gunther says Angelides is "brainy and engaging...a Left Coast version of Eliot Spitzer, ready to save capitalism from its worst excesses, and in so doing propel himself to higher office." "The Greeks gave us democracy, and Angelides wants to deliver nothing less to corporate America," Gunther writes, noting the current effort by Angelides and other institutional investors to change SEC rules to give shareholders easier access to nominating and electing directors.
What could be more socially responsible than democratic corporate governance? All the evidence we've seen indicates is should be a winning strategy. Arnold Schwarzenegger would do well to cooperate with Angelides, a man of visionary ideas.
