News on Open Ballot Measure From Dow Jones


更新时间:2003/11/08 阅读次数:164

Dow Jones reporters summarize efforts on open access issue in "From Leaflets To Web Sites, Investors Rally On Proxy Issue." They give well deserved credit to Les Greenberg for posting a couple of hundred messages on chat boards, encouraging readers to send comments to the SEC.

However, they also point out that the Council of Institutional Investors "handed out fliers on the streets of Washington near Metro stations telling passersby about the SEC's comment period. Shareholder activist Web site eRaider spread the word on its message boards. The California State Teachers' Retirement System became involved for the first time in corporate-governance outreach, devoting a section of its Web site for nine days to instructing visitors on how to send an e-mail to the SEC, along with suggested language for the missive; the link received 368 hits." It would be nice to know which of these efforts paid off.

I saw a short note on the CalSTRS site but missed the suggested language for e-mails to the SEC. Outreach to individual investors could have reached far more if large funds maintained e-mail addresses of their shareholders or members. CalPERS, for example, recently began offering an e-news services. The SEC would have received a lot more e-mail if CalPERS and others had mechanisms like this in place and had made use of them.

A couple of probable errors in the Dow Jones article:

  • "The only way for dissidents to reach shareholders with an alternative slate of directors is to launch a proxy contest, which can cost upwards of $25,000." While I suppose it is possible to run such a low budget campaign, the most frequently cited low figure is $250,000. I think they misplaced a zero.
  • They cite a quote from Bill Patterson and note he is from the "AFL-CIO, which sent a rule-making petition to the SEC earlier this year urging reform of the process." I don't think so. The SEC makes it a practice to post petitions for rulemakings submitted to the SEC on their internet site; there is nothing from the AFL-CIO this year on that subject. This is not to take anything away from their efforts, which have been essential in the current reform effort.

One quote was telling: "(SEC Chairman) Donaldson proposed it on his own initiative. The fact that he asked for this review suggests he thinks the idea has merit, and other members of the commission appear sympathetic," said James Heard, chief executive of proxy adviser Institutional Shareholder Services, which wrote to the SEC supporting more shareholder access to proxies.