Lavelle Favors Open Ballot


更新时间:2003/11/08 阅读次数:164

Louis Lavelle, who covers corporate governance for BusinessWeek, wrote a commentary for the July 2 edition entitled "Shareholder Democracy Is No Demon." Lavelle takes on several of the objections of opponents, such as the Business Roundtable and the American Society of Corporate Secretaries:

  • The "divisive" proxy contests predicted by opponents would be rare, given the fact that the typical recommended threshold of 3% "means anywhere from several to several dozen institutional shareholders would have to agree on a candidate slate."
  • Shareholder democracy would result in "balkanized" boards made up of special-interest directors say critics. Lavelle answers that the ideal board candidate is someone with forceful opinions who isn't afraid to share them. "What opponents fear probably isn't a divided board. It's that groups that have been largely banished from the boardroom -- namely labor and environmentalists -- might gain a foothold. But given the 3% ownership threshold, candidates advocating a radical labor or environmental agenda wouldn't be nominated, much less elected."
  • Unqualified nominees. "Any shareholder nominee would have to be thoroughly vetted to win the support of enough institutional investors to get on the proxy -- these are legitimate campaign issues that board-nominated director candidates could raise in the proxy."
  • Cost of allowing shareholder nominees on the proxy. Even assuming the exaggerated estimates of the American Society of Corporate Secretaries are correct, Lavelle says it would be "money well spent," about 4% of the average CEO's pay.
  • "Having more than one candidate for each open seat on the board, investors are told, could create "confusion" among shareholders, who are apparently quite capable of dissecting complex income statements but incapable of choosing between opposing slates." We've had two centuries of democracy in the political, its about time we tried it in business. "The sky isn't going to fall -- despite what Corporate America would have you believe."