Proxy Access: Presidential Issue?


更新时间:2003/11/08 阅读次数:116

Writing for Dow Jones, Neal Lipschutz raises the issue of where candidates stand on shareholders' right to nominate corporate directors. (see Point of View: Proxy Access And The Presidential Race, 7/8/03) "Hard to believe, for sure. But there are early indications that corporate governance may become an issue in next year's U.S. presidential election and the Democratic primaries that precede it."

"We've come a long way baby," is my response. Senator John Edwards recently announced, "I've proposed making sure that shareholders' nominees for corporate boards can compete with CEOs' picks on a level playing field." Edwards would:

  • Allow Shareholders to Nominate Directors. Edwards supports a proposal, now before the SEC, to allow large shareholders and groups of shareholders to nominate board members without waging a costly proxy fight. The SEC staff is expected to make a recommendation by July 15th.
  • Require Institutional Investors to Stand Up for Their Investors. Managers of mutual funds and pension funds have a fiduciary responsibility to represent their investors. Edwards would require fund managers with a substantial investment at stake to exercise the rights of ownership, unless they can demonstrate that doing so is not in the best interest of their investors. He would also require pension plans to disclose their votes on shareowner initiatives, like the SEC recently required mutual funds to do.
  • Fully Enforce the Edwards Amendment to Require Lawyer Accountability. Over the objection of the American Bar Association, Senator Edwards added a provision to the Sarbanes-Oxley Act to require that lawyers representing corporations put the interests of shareholders first. If the lawyers observe wrongdoing by insiders, they are now required by law to report that wrongdoing up the corporate ladder, to the board of directors if necessary. The SEC's implementing regulations muddled the law's requirements; Edwards would issue clearer regulations and fully enforce them.
  • Put the "Public" Back into Initial Public Offerings. Some Wall Street bankers have been able to game the system, selling underpriced shares to friends and potential clients that can be rapidly resold for large profits. Edwards would limit sales to insiders and their families and remove regulatory barriers to auctioning IPO shares.

Lipshutz concludes, "With war, homeland security and job losses in a sluggish economy front and center as the big issues for many Americans, it is hard to see the nascent political debate on corporate governance gaining resonance with too many voters. But, then again, there are many individual investors among the electorate, and a lot can happen before full-throttled campaigning even gets under way."