Canadian Companies Win Highest Overall Governance Rating


更新时间:2003/11/08 阅读次数:163

GovernanceMetrics International (GMI), an independent governance ratings agency, rated 1600 global companies from 15 countries. Seventeen companies - fifteen US and two Canadian, received scores of 10.0, GMI's highest rating (see below).

Canadian companies had the highest overall average rating of 7.2 followed closely by the UK, US and Australia. Companies with overall global ratings of 7.5 or more, which GMI considers above average, are almost exclusively from these four countries. In continental Europe, French companies scored the lowest with an average of 4.1, but the lowest governance performance of all was Japan, where the average rating was 3.5.

Even though US and Canadian firms scored well overall, there are still five companies from these two countries that received a global rating of 3.0 or less, which GMI considers well below average. This indicates that despite a strong legal and regulatory framework, companies can still satisfy basic requirements but represent a governance risk to shareholders. Sixteen companies received GMI's lowest rating of 1.0; of these, ten were Japanese, two were French, two were Dutch, and one Swiss and one American.

The highest scoring industries globally were Utilities (average rating of 7.0), Energy (6.9) and Insurance (6.8). The poorer performers were Construction (4.9), Autos (5.6) and Media (5.8). Not surprisingly, more regulated industries tended to have better governance practices overall, although GMI would have expected Financial Services as a regulated industry to have had better ratings overall than the 6.1 the industry achieved.

Noticeable differences were found in how companies performed in particular categories. In the area of potential dilution, Japanese companies scored well since stock options are generally not a feature of compensation practices in that country. On the other hand, of the 483 companies in the ratings universe with potential options dilution of 15% or more, all but seven were American. In financial disclosure, Japanese and European companies tended to score lower than US, Canadian, UK and Australian companies because of fewer disclosure requirements. In addition, 21% of the companies in the ratings do not report their accounts under US GAAP or International Accounting Standards practices, but under purely local standards. These companies are predominately Japanese and Continental European.

European corporations outperform in the area of broader stakeholder relations. In environmental, labor and social matters, European companies have far better practices and disclosure policies than US companies and consistently score better in this category.

GMI's Chief Executive Officer, Gavin Anderson said, "among the myriad of questionable practices we found are a chairman and president who were forced to resign because of bid rigging, but have now been re-hired as advisors; directors who sit on as many as fourteen public company boards as well as several committees; one director who collects a $600,000 annual consulting fee on top of his director fees, and one firm that does not designate either executive directors or a CEO and thus regulations relating to directors remuneration do not apply to them. What our ratings help determine is the culture of accountability and integrity at companies. We know from a number of studies that shareholders will pay a premium for companies with good corporate governance."

GMI's rating system incorporates more than 600 data points across seven broad categories of analysis, including board accountability, disclosure, executive compensation, shareholder rights, ownership base, takeover provisions and corporate behavior and social responsibility. Subscribers to GMI are able to view a company's overall rating, section ratings and several pages of written analysis. The firm also utilizes a "red flag" alert to identify areas that it believes investors should pay particular attention to.


Companies with a global score of 10 (highest rating) were:
Alcan Inc. (Canada)
McDonald's Corporation (US)
BCE Inc. (Canada)
Petroleum Corporation (US)
ChevronTexaco Corporation (US)
PepsiCo, Inc. (US)
Chubb Corporation (US)
Pfizer Inc. (US)
Colgate-Palmolive Company (US)
Pinnacle west Capital (US)
E.I. DuPont de Nemours & Co. (US)
Praxair Inc. (US)
Eastman Kodak Company (US)
SLM Corporation (US)
Exxon Mobil Corporation (US)
The Allstate Corporation (US)
Gillette Company (US)