Now a shareholder, Walter Baer, is alleging that the brokerage firm squelched the outcome of a vote on one of its funds -- Latin American Discovery Fund. Baer's proposal was to convert this closed-end fund into an "interval" fund -- such funds make tender offers to buy back shares on a regular basis but do not trade, as do closed-end funds -- in the belief that this would help eliminate a persistent discount to its net-asset value.
Barron's Online points out that Baer is a senior analyst at Rand Corp. He was among the first to call for the federal government to establish the now-famous "do-not-call" list, banishing unwanted telemarketers, and to write research on e-mail. In the 1980s, he was chief technology officer for Times Mirror...maybe more than Morgan Stanley had bargained on.
According to Baer's tally, his proposal won 61% of the votes cast (47% of all shares outstanding) -- but the press release issued by Morgan Stanley on June 13th states: "The Fund noted the results of the voting on a stockholder proposal to recommend that the Board of Directors act to adopt interval-fund status for the Fund. Less than a majority of the Fund's outstanding shares, and less than a majority of the shares represented at the annual meeting, voted in favor of this proposal." (see Yahoo!)
According to Baer, "Morgan Stanley resorted to an irrelevant apples-to-oranges comparison with the shares 'represented at the meeting,' in an attempt to use smoke and mirrors and avoid properly conveying the voting outcome in their press release." "They lost, but chose to ignore it." For shareholder proposals the outcome is decided based on the number of people who actually cast a vote -- not the number of votes present, which often includes broker non-votes, a much larger denominator.
Baer concedes: "They've done nothing illegal. I just believe it's misrepresenting what the shareholders voted for. And Morgan Stanley would be well advised to take a vote of 61% of shares cast seriously, particularly at a time when people want improved corporate governance ."
In a reply to Baer, fund president Ronald Robison wrote a letter: "In general, it is unlikely that the Board of Directors of a Fund will accord a proposal any significant weight unless it is approved by the holders of a substantial majority of the Fund's outstanding shares."
Other shareholders were stunned. "Will Morgan Stanley CEO Phil Purcell, on the board of these funds, choose to ignore this matter, coming so soon after he and Morgan Stanley ran into hot water for their cavalier attitude about the monumental $1.4 billion Wall Street settlement?" asks another longtime closed-end fund investor and shareholder in the fund, Adam Shapiro of Advantage Capital Management.
Their action, or inaction, certainly lends support to the SEC's suggested changes to regulations that address how corporate boards are nominated. Morgan Stanley seems intent on being among the first to pull the SEC's trigger. (Greener Pastures: Votes Cast Aside, Barron's Online, 7/21/03)
