A simulation by Innovest for a major US pension fund found that a slight "tilt" toward certain SRI criteria resulted in gains averaging 1% for five of six portfolios, with the one fund only underperforming by 0.04%.
The Innovest results directly contradicted the findings of a recently publicized study from the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania. That study concluded that including socially responsible investment factors could cost active investors as much 3.6% per annum in lost performance.
Bijan Foroodian, Innovest's Director of Quantitative Analysis says "The Wharton study appears to be fundamentally flawed" since it compares the performance of broadly - based SRI funds with a group of 28 mainstream equity funds, of which fully 17 are real estate funds. "Given the enormous differentials in the risk/return characteristics of these two different types of investments, this comparison is, at best, disingenuous."
Additionally, Innovest points to the Wharton study's primary focus on social funds practicing exclusionary, negative screening as falling short of more advanced techniques used in the construction of social conscience criteria. Instead, SRI portfolios designed to maximize performance should be stressing positive screens and must discriminate among the various social performance metrics; clearly they do not all have equal financial impact.
Going forward, there is every reason to believe that this "SRI premium" will become even larger in future. The Innovest simulation identifies six powerful global "mega-trends" which can be expected to further increase the importance of SRI factors:
The Innovest results directly contradicted the findings of a recently publicized study from the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania. That study concluded that including socially responsible investment factors could cost active investors as much 3.6% per annum in lost performance.
Bijan Foroodian, Innovest's Director of Quantitative Analysis says "The Wharton study appears to be fundamentally flawed" since it compares the performance of broadly - based SRI funds with a group of 28 mainstream equity funds, of which fully 17 are real estate funds. "Given the enormous differentials in the risk/return characteristics of these two different types of investments, this comparison is, at best, disingenuous."
Additionally, Innovest points to the Wharton study's primary focus on social funds practicing exclusionary, negative screening as falling short of more advanced techniques used in the construction of social conscience criteria. Instead, SRI portfolios designed to maximize performance should be stressing positive screens and must discriminate among the various social performance metrics; clearly they do not all have equal financial impact.
Going forward, there is every reason to believe that this "SRI premium" will become even larger in future. The Innovest simulation identifies six powerful global "mega-trends" which can be expected to further increase the importance of SRI factors:
- Changing demographics for both consumers and investors, substantially increasing the saliency and financial stakes of companies’ environmental and social performance.
- Tightening national, regional, and global regulatory requirements for stronger performance and disclosure on SRI issues.
- Growing pressures from the international non-governmental organizations (NGO’s), armed with unprecedented resources, credibility, and global communication platforms.
- A substantial broadening of the purview of what is considered to be the legitimate fiduciary responsibility of investors to include addressing companies’ social and environmental performance. (In the U.K. and a number of other European countries, this enlarged view of fiduciary responsibility has been enshrined in law).
- The globalization and intensification of industrial competition, particularly into emerging markets, exponentially increasing the level of environmental and social risk for major corporations and investors.
- A growing inclination – and capability – among major institutional investors for shareholder activism on environmental and social issues.
