Basically, although this individual recognized that CalPERS must stop excess payments once the courts made their final determination, they questioned requiring board members to return what they have already been paid.
The following is an abbreviated list of their questions and concerns:
Would Kurato Shimada (and others) have to give back $300 for each day he participated in Board meetings? I know it's the principle, but Shimada attended Board meetings under what could certainly be interpreted as a contract that paid him $400/day. Shimada accepted that contract, and put in the time…
What about the release time allowed for state employees on the Board? How could that be recovered? These members' agencies received upwards of 60% of the members' total compensation to replace them for the time away from their jobs for CalPERS responsibilities…. These members put in the time for CalPERS and did not put in that time for their agency. They didn't receive any additional compensation.
My Response: The court did not make new law in handing down its decision; it simply affirmed the existing law. In its lawsuit against AOL Time Warner, CalPERS is not simply asking the company to cease its illegal activities, CalPERS is rightfully seeking disgorgement of insider-trading proceeds; restitution of defrauded monies; damages sustained as a result of wrongdoing, etc. Similarly, allowing board members to keep payments, which the courts have determined are excessive would be wrong. Yes, they should pay the excess amounts back, regardless of the “contract” they made with themselves.
With regard to the release time: I’m not asking CalPERS to recover those monies now. But if someone takes CalPERS to court, they very well might. They would also seek reasonable costs and expenses, including fees for legal counsel, which might be as much as the money actually recovered. However, you are right “it’s the principle.” Board members should not personally benefit/profit from activities of questionalble legality. That principle is much more important than the relatively small amount of money involved. If CalPERS fiduciaries disagree with that principle, members and beneficiaries are in trouble.
At least in the case of release time the “benefit” accrued to public agencies, not to individuals. Those public agencies had no say in creating the policy that resulted in higher reimbursements to them. They granted additional release time in good faith and had no reason to believe the board policy wasn't proper. On the other hand, the payments were in excess of legally allowable amounts and should be recovered in order to make system participants and their beneficiaries whole.
The case against board members who directly received increased compensation is clear. They made the decision to raise their own reimbursement from the legally set $100 per diem to $400 and they also raised their own travel reimbursement to amounts above legal limits.
I certainly do not know all the history behind the issue but I can sketch a few facts relevant to me that preceded the lawsuit.
Soon after Proposition 162 passed, the board asked a series of questions of outside counsel, Joe Wyatt Jr., concerning their legal authority. As I recall, Wyatt expressed his expert opinion that the board was not exempt from civil service laws, the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) and other statutes. California Constitution article 16, section 17 provides some latitude to the board where a statute conflicts with the board’s ability to fulfill its fiduciary duties. According to BPAC agenda item 4, page 4 (May 18, 1999) “Counsel has also advised that the Board will have the burden of proving necessity, should the action be challenged in court.”
In BPAC agenda item 5A (April 14, 1998) staff (Kayla Gillan, General Counsel) presented four alternatives with regard to raising board compensation. She recommended that the Committee “focus on possible legislative alternatives.” (her emphasis)
As you may or may not know, after substantial adverse press, testimony before the board and legislature by myself and others concerning the acceptance by board members of campaign contributions and gifts, the board enacted several “policies” (resolutions BD-98-01, BD-98-02 and BD-98-03) on 2/19/98 requiring disclosure of solicitations, gifts and banned certain campaign contributions. On 2/21/98 I petitioned CalPERS pursuant to Government Code section 11340.6, requesting promulgation of the policies as regulations pursuant to the APA. CalPERS declined to do so. I then sought a determination regarding the legality of the regulations from the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) on 5/1/98.
I had primarily two concerns. First, CalPERS should not violate the APA, which requires public notice, opportunity for comment and other protections when adopting regulations. Additionally, I was concerned the board would simply repeal the policies after press coverage of excesses ended. That would be much more difficult if they had to follow the APA to repeal the regulations.
Separately, the political committee “Kathleen Connell for Controller” challenged the validity of two of the resolutions resulting in a judgment by Sacramento Superior Court on 9/28/98, which found both resolutions invalid, since they “constitute regulations which were promulgated without compliance with the Administrative Procedure Act.” In Determination No. 18, dated 8/11/99, OAL found all three policies invalid for the same reasons. The board had claimed the California Constitution exempts it from the APA, arguing that Constitutional provisions giving the board “plenary authority and fiduciary responsibility for investment of moneys and administration of the system…” exempt it from oversight or control by any other executive branch agency or statute. That argument was thoroughly rejected by the Superior Court.
When the board acted to raise their own salaries and travel reimbursement rates they did so knowing full well that they were very likely to be exceeding their authority based on the opinion of outside counsel, OAL’s determination and the prior court decision.
I also find the board’s logic for violating the Government Code limitations on their own reimbursements hypocritical. Board members advocating the pay increase claimed they would be violating their fiduciary duty spelled out in the Constitution because if they didn’t the board wouldn’t be able to attract competent candidates. However, at the same time they were attempting to enact regulations governing those elections which a Sacramento Bee editorial said “risk creation of a permanent board: unaccountable, untouchable and isolated from the people who elect it.” (CalPERS muzzles critics: Ballot rules protect board, keep others in the dark, May 25, 1999) You don’t attract more competent candidates by prohibiting them from discussing why they are running in the ballot statement.
Regardless of the board’s motivation, now that the courts have determined that the payments exceed what the law allows, board members should voluntarily turn the excessive amounts back to the system.
