Putting Investors First


更新时间:2003/11/03 阅读次数:152

Putting Investors First: Real Solutions for Better Corporate Governance, by Scott C. Newquist and Max B. Russell offers a great guide to CEOs, directors, shareholders and their fiduciaries. From pay for performance, based primarily on options, to the accounting games and how they are played, Newquist and Russell step their readers through a lack of checks, balances and accountability, that have had serious consequences.

Central to their argument is that CEOs have “circumvented governance mechanisms by supplying the board with information that is incomplete, inaccurate, or incomprehensible.” For many shareholders, their most effective action would be to sell but to properly evaluate their options they need complete and accurate information. “The ultimate fix is up to boards of directors. They must reassert their power and accept fully their responsibilities and obligations to protect shareholders’ interests.”

Newquist and Russell see through the limited promise of box ticking guidelines, including most of those recently enacted in Sarbanes-Oxley. Enron would have all but loans to officers. They seek to move us away from “just-in-time-governance” and “governance by embarrassment” to principles, “supported by mechanisms that stress accountability, disclosure, performance measurement, and checks and balances. “Principles-based governance benefits from scrutiny, debate, and most of all, transparency.”

Among the recommended mechanisms are:
  • Requiring directors to also sign off on financial statements, with a “to the best of my knowledge” qualifier.
  • An annual meeting between independent directors and institutional investors webcast to all.
  • Disclosure of dissenting opinions on important issues and board votes as soon as practical.
  • Split CEO and chair or a strong independent director with an out “if the CEO is the only insider on the board and is totally committed to transparency and accountability.” (An out I would likely question)
  • Independent information sources and analytical capability for board members.

There are many more excellent suggestions. However, I did express one serious reservation. Read what became an exchange with Scott Newquist.