October 8th, Mark Your Calendar!


更新时间:2003/11/03 阅读次数:119

An understated announcement on October 1st indicates the SEC will hold an open meeting on Wednesday, October 8. One of the subjects will be the following:

  • The Commission will consider whether to propose amendments to certain Rules, Schedules and Forms under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and the Investment Company Act of 1940 that would require companies, under certain circumstances, to include in their proxy materials security holder nominees for election as director. For further information, please contact Lillian Cummins Brown at (202) 942-2900.

Sixty-three years after the Commission originally proposed giving shareholders access to the proxy to nominate directors, it appears they are ready to try again, essentially taking up the petition Les Greenberg and I submitted in the summer of 2002. Let's hope nothing as distracting as World War II gets in the way this time.

The Business Roundtable is certainly giving distraction and further postponement a try. Their letter of October 1st suggests "the SEC undertake additional research into the impact of various triggers and thresholds before proceeding with proposed rules concerning shareholder access." (my emphasis) The BRT is "concerned that some of the triggering events in the Report will result in the application of shareholder access to most, if not all, companies rather than only companies where there has not been an effective proxy process."

The SEC has indicated their rule may propose a 3% threshold for shareholders. However, the BRT said a stock ownership threshold of 25% should be required to justify "the costs and disruption" of board elections. Additionally, they point out that "proxy voting guidelines of many institutional investors and the voting recommendations of proxy advisory services are likely to be revised to support shareholder access proposals at all companies, if for no other reason than to make shareholder access available in case a company is not responsive to shareholders in the future." Instead, the BRT wants at least a two year window, and that's for a rule that would only allow shareholders to nominate a few, certainly less than half, of the board members.

Will the SEC listen to the BRT, an association representing the CEOs of corporations with a combined workforce of 10 million employees and $3.7 trillion in annual revenues, or will they listen to CII, an organization that represents the owners of over $2 trillion in such companies, the AFL-CIO, which represents more than 13 million working men and women, as well as the vast majority of investors who sent in comments in response to the SEC's Solicitation of Public Views Regarding Possible Changes to the Proxy Rules? Watch for coverage in the Dow Jones newsletter Corporate Governance, (see complimentary subscription offer for readers of CorpGov.Net), ISS Friday Report and other timely publications.