Should CEOs Allow Shareholders to Nominate Board Candidates?


更新时间:2003/11/03 阅读次数:125

Chief Executive, which bills itself as "the only magazine written strictly for CEOs and their peers," includes an article entitled "Shareholder Democracy" in its October issue. "As the leading source of intelligence for and about CEOs," Chief Executive "provides ideas, strategies and tactics for top executive leaders seeking to build more effective organizations."

Should CEOs take democracy seriously? Readers of Chief Executive are likely to conclude they should. Author Gregory J. Millman states, "When staunch members of the financial establishment start speaking the same language as labor unions and reform groups, it suggests that CEOs face a Hobson's choice: share power voluntarily or see it taken away."

The article begins with "traitor to his class," Robert A.G. Monks, "pinching himself, almost afraid to believe that the cause he's championed for so long is now gaining steam." Millman then describes MCI, where former SEC Chairman Richard Breeden as court monitor published 78 recommendations, including that "CEOs consider...allowing shareholders to nominate board candidates." That seems to this editor to be a telling quote. If the SEC goes forward with its rulemaking, will it be because CEOs allowed it?

Near the end of the article Bob Monks predicts that CEOs will do all they can to defend the status quo. "One would think that the first place opponents would turn would be the White House," he says, adding that, based on recent history, they would likely find a sympathetic ear. He also believes the Business Roundtable might bring a suit, claiming the SEC has exceeded its authority.

Normally, I love a story that gives me the last word, but in this case it simply reflects realism and the relatively minor impact the groundbreaking SEC rule is likely to have initially. "As shareholder advocate Jim McRitchie, editor of CorpGov.net, notes, that (the rule) would effectively require shareholders to form broad, unwieldy coalitions just to muster a nominating quorum, because even the largest institutional investor rarely owns 3 percent. He and others also believe that allowing shareholders to nominate candidates only after such a 'triggering event' would mean closing the barn door after the horse had already run away."

If we're lucky, adoption of an SEC rule will trigger enough additional future reforms to make boards responsible to shareholders, instead of CEOs. CEOs shouldn't be in a position of allowing or prohibiting shareholder access to the ballot; that's a decision that should be left to shareholders themselves.