Investors Deserve a True Voice in Board Elections


更新时间:2003/11/03 阅读次数:146

American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), AFL-CIO, released two polls providing new insight into corporate board elections on the eve of an SEC rule making to enhance proxy access for director nominations. The key findings of the Harris Interactive survey of more than 1,000 individual investors, show:
  • Eighty percent think there should be a process to allow shareholders to nominate candidates for boards of directors;
  • Ninety percent agree that corporate misconduct has weakened investor confidence in the stock market;
  • More than half of the shareholders agree that corporate management is not in the best position to decide who should be nominated to the board of directors.

A large majority of these investors also believe shareholders should have access to corporate proxy materials to nominate board member candidates rather than leaving the decision solely in the hands of corporate management. Currently, any shareholders who want to challenge an incumbent board member has to pay hundreds of thousands, even millions, of dollars to run their own candidates.

AFSCME says new rules being considered by the SEC should adhere to the following principles:

  • Access to the proxy should be granted when an investor group with substantial ownership in the company seeks to nominate a director.
  • Investors should be long-term shareholders with the long-term interests of the company in mind, not short-term market manipulators.
  • This right should be available to elect less than a majority of investors-the new rules should not assist hostile takeovers but rather should be a tool to reform corporate boards to make them more accountable to shareholders.
  • Investors must be able to use these rules in a timely manner so that they will impact corporate conduct in the shortest period of time possible.

Later the same day, Sean Harrigan, president of the Board of Administration of CalPERS, testified before the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs. Harrigan suggested strengthening, auditor independence, financial reporting, federal securities laws, and the resources of the SEC, including: enforcing an outright ban on audit firms performing non-audit services; developing internal controls over financial reporting; giving the SEC a greater degree of independence from the federal budget process; and studying whether the SEC should have additional authority to ban individuals from serving as an officer or director at public companies convicted of misconduct.

Harrigan told the committee that the single most important reform that everyone should support is the ability of shareholders to have access to the proxy to nominate directors.

"At the heart of many problems that face investors is a lack of accountability of board members to the owners of the corporation," Harrigan said. "The root causes of problems like abusive executive compensation, lack of oversight that helps permit fraud and plain old poor performance is the lack of accountability of board members to their owners. A reasonable and balanced approach to providing investors with greater access to management's proxy statement will directly address this problem."