More Pressure on Grasso


更新时间:2003/11/03 阅读次数:132

Four of America's largest public pension funds -- two in California, one in New York and one in North Carolina, with combined assets of $401 billion -- asked Grasso to step down. They asserted his $139.5 million deferred-pay package is too much, particularly amid efforts by U.S. companies to shore up their governance standards as the nation's stock markets recover from an unprecedented period of corporate fraud.

"This pay package is out of line and it's part of a sickness of culture in this country where too many at the very top have forgotten what's right and fair in the American economy and what average workers make in this country," argued California state treasurer Phil Angelides, who along with the heads of the California Public Employees' Retirement System (or CalPERS) and the head of the California State Teachers' Retirement System expressed their dismay to Mr. Grasso in a letter Tuesday. They asserted that it would take an average American 5,200 years working a 40-hour workweek to receive the money Mr. Grasso has received.

The NYSE is supposed to represent the interests of investors. In their letter to Mr. Grasso, the California pension funds and Mr. Angelides said: "The pay package sends the wrong signal at this critical time when public and private sector leaders must be steadfast in their commitment to restoring the credibility of our financial markets." They added: "It is particularly troubling that the most substantial amounts paid under the agreement were for a time period when the NYSE fell short of its central regulatory mission, as Americans endured the greatest wave of corporate scandals since the market manipulations of the 1920s."

In addition to his retirement package, Mr. Grasso received a $30.5 million pay package in 2001, nearly equal to the Big Board's net income that year. Mr. Grasso's 2001 pay included a one-time $5 million bonus for the leadership role he played in re-opening the exchange after the Sept. 11 terror attacks. Now, his decision to accept that money is under attack. Mr. Angelides said he wasn't aware of one firefighter or one police officer or even the mayor of New York "or anyone else having gotten a $5 million bonus for doing the right thing by America." (Large Investors Issue Call
For Grasso to Leave NYSE, 9/17/02, WSJ)

Epilogue: Grasso resigned as chairman and chief executive of the NYSE on 9/17/03 after the board voted 13 to 7 during a conference call to ask him to resign in order to restore investor confidence in the world's largest stock market.

Five years ago Grasso was a member of the board of Computer Associates International and witnessed investor fury when the company tried to pay its senior executives more than $1 billion in stock. You'd think he might have learned from that experience. Grasso fought for more than two weeks to preserve his job and a lump-sum payment of nearly $140 million, even agreeing to forgo an additional $48 million he was "entitled to receive" over the next four years.

Oh the sacrifices some people are willing to make; but it was too little, to late. By handpicking members of his own the compensation committee that set his pay, Grasso set a poor example for companies the NYSE "regulates." Grasso's resignation marks an end to an embarrassing episode for the exchange but I hope it doesn't end the controversy over how the exchange should be run. Conflicts of interest at the NYSE should be minimized. Critics have argued the SEC should divide the NYSE into two institutions, one to manage the exchange and one to regulate it, following the model of the Nasdaq and NASD. Will that be part of the plan the NYSE submits this fall? I'd like to see something more creative, with actual investor advocates sitting on the board. Let's get rid of NYSE's constitutional provision that requires that securities industry representatives take up 12 of the 27 seats on the board.