Average is Best?


更新时间:2003/11/03 阅读次数:125

According to a recent study of 1,600 firms by GovernanceMetrics International Inc., companies with the worst corporate governance ratings returned 5.4% for the 12 months ended Aug. 12, compared with 11% for all stocks rated. The Dow Jones Industrial Average gained 9.7% in the 12 months ended Aug. 12. Over three years, the worst corporations lost an average of 13% a year compared with a loss of 1.8% for all companies. The Dow Jones industrials lost an average of 3.7% annually during that period. Highly rated firms beat those currently rated near the bottom over five and 10 years as well.

"But good governance doesn't automatically make you rich," according to the report in the Wall Street Journal. "While bad governance makes for bad returns, buying companies with top-notch governance won't necessarily mean higher returns. While the companies that get top governance scores did best during the past three years, corporations with average ratings won the five- and 10-year contests." (Weak Boardrooms And Weak Stocks Go Hand in Hand, WSJ, 9/9/03)

That seeming anomaly is easily explained. Many companies with the best corporate governance are the recent beneficiaries of intervention by activist shareholders like Ralph Whitworth, Burt Denton, and Andrew Shapiro who have been, in Maureen Nevin Duffy's terms, "pushing back." They've taken poorly performing companies and turned them around by instituting corporate governance reforms. Ms. Duffy's Corporate Governance Fund Report is the only publication systematically following these crusaders.

Duffy provides coverage of the recent Council of Institutional Investors meeting. She reports that Ralph Whitworth said everyone knows “you have to dance with the one that brought you to the dance.” When push comes to shove corporate board members are more likely to vote with the one who put them on the board. Shareholders “have to get a ticket to the dance.” Open access to the corporate ballot would provide that ticket. Whitworth contends that none of the now notorious companies like Tyco and Enron would've set off a trigger event under upcoming SEC rules. “The issue is to be proactive not reactive. If board members felt truly vulnerable under challenge,” most companies would respond.

Other factors being equal, over the long run, companies with excellent corporate governance will provide excellent returns. That's what I'm betting on.