The Fall 2003 edition of “Strategy + Business,” carries an informative article on one of the gods of modern business literature, Charles Handy. A good summary of Handy’s influence is found in a quote from Warren Bennis, “If Peter Drucker is responsible for legitimizing the field of management and Tom Peters for popularizing it, then Charles Handy should be known as the person who gave it a philosophical elegance and eloquence that was missing from the field.”
Lawrence M. Fisher begins with a stroll in one of England’s small villages where Charles Handy and his wife Elizabeth make their home. He explains that one of Handy’s early insights was that organizations aren’t inanimate objects but vibrant microcosms of human societies. Those who seek to manage companies need to understand the motivations of individuals and how collective behavior determines organizational behavior.
In his second book, Gods of Management, Handy saw us moving from corporate cultures built around the founder (Zeus) and bureaucracy (Apollo) to collaborative teams (Athena) and independent specialists (Dionysus).
Fisher goes on to portray an intellectual journey to the point that now Handy has come to believe that “a company ought to be a community, a community that you belong to, like a village.” “Nobody owns a village. You are a member and you have rights. Shareholders will become financiers, and they will get rewarded according to the risk they assume, but they’re not to be called owners. And workers won’t be workers, they’ll be citizens and they will have rights. And those rights will include a share in the profits they have created.”
And just what would such a company look like? Building on Handy’s work, Brook Manville and Josiah Ober begin to give us the outline in A Company of Citizens: What the World’s First democracy Teaches Leaders About Creating Great Organizations (2003). The authors provide readers with a wealth of information concerning the rise of Athenian democracy and the importance of harnessing the knowledge of people who have an innate desire to have a part in controlling their own destiny.
From citizens paying dramatists with public funds to expose the foibles of institutions and leaders to intricate systems designed to ensure artificial social networks stimulate the exchange of ideas, Manville and Ober present many interesting details. There is much here worth borrowing, from team-based rotating leadership to transparency of information to ensure group decisions had a solid foundation.
They appear to accept Handy’s suggestion, from The Hungry Spirit (1998), that companies should issue two classes of shares – voting shares for members of the company and some major stakeholders – nonvoting shares for more casual or short-term investors. People need to take center stage in terms of rewards and honors at most companies where human knowledge is the prime creator wealth. Handy sees the rights of citizenship being extended in some limited way to part-timers, freelancers, as well as suppliers and investors.
Elsewhere I have written of the need to reassess the role of antitakeover defenses, suggesting that instead of using poison pills, firm specific human capital could be better protected through bylaw amendments that require employee approval of changes in ownership. (see "ATDs Issues Not Simple" in August 2003 News)
Where are we likely to see such democratic companies arise? Based on Handy’s writings, as extended by Manville and Ober, we’ll find them where
- Companies have a clear sense of their own mission and goals -- where the company of citizens believes the goals can best be achieved through collective action.
- The nature of the work and the performance challenges demand large-scale cooperation and collaboration. Traditional hierarchies may work well enough for routine activities but as work relies increasingly on knowledge, democracy is a better fit.
- The need for fresh ideas and management approaches require regular changes in leadership.
Perhaps two of the most important factors are relatively high employee ownership and unionization. One indicates commitment to the firm, the other is a crucible of democracy in the workplace.
