Writing in December's ISSue Alert, Stephen Deane sees a storm brewing between US led globalization and European national or regional sovereignty. Europeans question US accounting and tax structures which disadvantage shareholders. Specifically, not expensing option grants to income statements (if they had, earnings per share would have dropped 9% in 2000) and allowing a tax deduction when employees exercise their options (companies get to write off the difference between strike price and market value).
The Council of Institutional Investors has long advocated recognizing stock option grants as an expense. Even accounting firms Deloitte & Touche and Arthur Anderson agree. The International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) drew fire in September when it announced that one of its top priorities is to develop a global standard for the accounting treatment of stock options.
Let's hope Congress has learned from the Enron scandal and keeps out of accounting standards setting this time. Unfortunately, Deane reports that is not the case. Michael Oxley (R-Ohio), who chairs the House Financial Services Committee, has fired off letters to the IASB, the US Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and the US Securities and Exchange Commission warning that requiring companies to expense options "would sharply diminish their use, harming American workers in a profound way."
In our opinion there is just about no action that could help American workers more than proper accounting. Yes, a few greedy CEOs could be hurt but let's hope the Europeans win.
