CalPERS: The Watchdog That Failed to Bark


更新时间:2003/11/03 阅读次数:162

According to a widely published article originating with the New York Times, the CalPERS Board was warned by outside advisors that Enron's chief financial officer, Andrew Fastow would face conflicts of interest between his duties to the LJM 3 limited partnership, which he pitched to CalPERS, and Enron. Disclosure of such an investment could lead to embarrassment for CalPERS, especially to its reputation as a corporate governance activist.

Roland Machold, a co-founder of the Council of Institutional Investors, said he wondered why the pension fund managers "did not go right to the board, as it used to do in the old days, and say they were concerned that the board had approved something so conflicted."

Prompt action by the CalPERS Board, such as talking with the Enron board or putting Enron on their focus list, might have made a huge difference to California taxpayers. Stock losses totaled more than $248 million at California pension funds alone, to say nothing of the $325 million loss suffered by the Florida state pension fund and additional losses at other public pension funds.

Why didn't the world's most famous corporate watchdog bark? The Board's own conflicts of interest may have played a part. Bob Carlson (Board member since 1971) serves on the board of 12 Franklin funds. Bill Crist (Board member since 1987) also served on the board of the Pacific Rim Prosperity fund for many years. Which fiduciary duty gets a higher priority when opportunity knocks or conflicts arise, CalPERS or the private investment funds?

Between stints on the CalPERS Board, Kurato Shimada, (served 1987-1999, reelected in 2001) along with former Board member Albert Villalobos and retired state senator William Campbell lobbied the Board to invest $250 million in the CIM California Urban Real Estate Fund. It was the first vote ever attempted without a staff recommendation in the pension fund's 68-year history. Is Shimada more concerned with members or building placement fee opportunities (typically 1% of the investment)?

Many Board members continue to accept expensive entertainment, diners and other gifts from those contracting with the System. In direct violation of the Government Code, they raised their own salaries and were subsequently sued by State Controller Kathleen Connell. With such conflicts of interest on their own Board, it is not surprising that CalPERS took no action to further investigate Enron.

If they had read Enron's SEC filings, the following should have lead to questions (see 10-K's: A Good Read for the Curious Investor, New York Times, 1/20/02):

  • Enron director, John Urquhart was paid $493,914 for providing consulting services to Enron.
  • Enron director, Lord John Wakeham, received $72,000 for advice on Enron's European operations.
  • Enron director Herbert Winokur was affiliated with the privately owned National Tank Co. that made sales to Enron worth $370,294.
  • Sharon Lay, sister of Enron chairman and chief executive Ken Lay, was paid $517,200 for travel services provided to the firm.

Additionally, they would have noticed Enron not only avoided paying income taxes in four of the last five years, it also collected $381 million in tax "refunds." Maybe that wouldn't have mattered to the CalPERS Board. After all, 18 year Board member Charles Valdes largely avoided paying taxes for seven years and declared bankruptcy twice while serving as the Chairman of the Board's Investment Committee.

How can we end conflicts of interest in corporations when our own pension funds, even those with excellent reputations such as CalPERS, are riddled with such conflicts themselves? CalPERS and other public pension funds should use the Enron scandal as an opportunity for self-examination. Public employee pension funds that invest in tax evading corporations are like police who sell criminals their guns. They're not following a good long-term strategy. (CalPERS knew of problem but kept silent: State pension fund didn't share data on executives' conflicts, San Francisco Chronicle, 2/5/)