Dim View of Bidding for Class Actions


更新时间:2003/11/03 阅读次数:145

A study commissioned by a federal appeals court has taken a dim view of a controversial practice adopted by some federal judges in big securities class actions-asking law firms vying to represent plaintiffs to bid for the assignment. A study commissioned by the Philadelphia-based U.S.

Circuit Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit concluded last month that competitive bidding for class action counsel positions is generally a bad idea. Plaintiffs lawyers often jockey for the position of lead counsel, hoping for the biggest fee. Without a bidding process, the choice is made at the sole discretion of the judge presiding over a case. "The risks and complications associated with a judicially-controlled auction counsel against its use except under certain limited circumstances," the 3rd Circuit task force concluded in its final report on Jan. 17.

How limited? Of the 14 cases in which competitive bidding was used, only one fit the panel's criteria. While the 3rd Circuit's chief judge, Edward Becker, has said the task force doesn't speak for the court, the report gives class action lawyers with cases in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and the Virgin Islands weighty ammunition for arguments against bidding for work. Time will test how other circuits react, but U.S. Judges Vaughn Walker of the Northern District of California and Milton Shadur of the Northern District of Illinois are already on record as saying the panel's work was flawed and failed to give credit to the good points of bidding. (Legal Times, 2/4, Study Frowns On Class Action Auctions 3rd Circuit Task Force Says Judges Should Significantly Limit Their Use Of Competitive Bidding For Class Action Counsel)